Search Historic Hotels in Manhattan

"This was an excellent location (a few blocks from central park, ten minutes from Times Square, easy subway access). It also provided the desired New York City vibe and ambience. "

"Good "

"Rooms are dated. Fixtures were rusty and broken. Can't close bathroom door with the shower mat down. A/C malfunctioned leaving room either freezing or 87 degrees. Lobby needs a remodel to tear out the old bar which isn’t functional. Rooftop pool is tiny. Gym is small and outdated and was randomly closed. Ventilation system needs a thorough cleaning. Staff tried to be professional, but security burst into our room at 11:58pm to investigate a "noise complaint" that was my kid's white noise machine trying to drown out street noise. No call. No knock. Just burst in the room giving my kids a fright and nightmares. Location is about all it has going. "

"I have always stayed at the Hotel Edison when traveling to NY. Marco - at the front desk is amazing…he remembers his returning guests and treats us royally. If it wasn’t for Marco I would try different hotels. Yes - the rooms are starting to get tired but the location can’t be beat. Thank you for a wonderful stay."

"Very kind front desk staff, but all else is mediocre. Elevators need service, rooms are cramped, towels are paper thin, cracked paint, and bad water pressure. Front desk let me check in early and check out was easy, but I would be hard pressed to stay here again. "

"We had a great experience here traveling as a family. Would definitely stay again. "

"We had a wonderful visit at this nostalgic hotel. The staff was excellent. Fantastic location."

"The room was cleaned with fresh towels everyday. The staff were very kind and friendly. The room had a broken mirrored door and the bath/shower kept clogging. But these are all fixable things. Unfortunately our neighbours were smoking weed so them stench of that was not ideal, especially with a teenager who has severe asthma, but this is not a reflection on the hotel. Shower gel shampoo and conditioner was provided. Hairdryer provided. No hot drink facilities which was the only disappointing part for me. There is no fridge but there is an ice bucket with an ice machine on the floor to fill and keep drinks cool. There is a deli across the street which sell coffee for $2.50 so again, not a huge concern. The property is in an EXCELLENT location. I would 100% stay again. "

"The hotel staff was top notch. So kind and accommodating. They went above and beyond. The market was very convenient. The rooms were nothing special, but clean and comfortable. Would def stay here again! "