Compare and book 4 Star hotels in Theater District, New York

"Room clean and air condition set at the right temperature.. staff vey helpful and courteous "

"Staff was amazing, clean room & very friendly "

"I have always stayed at the Hotel Edison when traveling to NY. Marco - at the front desk is amazing…he remembers his returning guests and treats us royally. If it wasn’t for Marco I would try different hotels. Yes - the rooms are starting to get tired but the location can’t be beat. Thank you for a wonderful stay."

"Very kind front desk staff, but all else is mediocre. Elevators need service, rooms are cramped, towels are paper thin, cracked paint, and bad water pressure. Front desk let me check in early and check out was easy, but I would be hard pressed to stay here again. "

"The room was cleaned with fresh towels everyday. The staff were very kind and friendly. The room had a broken mirrored door and the bath/shower kept clogging. But these are all fixable things. Unfortunately our neighbours were smoking weed so them stench of that was not ideal, especially with a teenager who has severe asthma, but this is not a reflection on the hotel. Shower gel shampoo and conditioner was provided. Hairdryer provided. No hot drink facilities which was the only disappointing part for me. There is no fridge but there is an ice bucket with an ice machine on the floor to fill and keep drinks cool. There is a deli across the street which sell coffee for $2.50 so again, not a huge concern. The property is in an EXCELLENT location. I would 100% stay again. "

"There is only one reference for breakfast and it would close by 10:30 AM always a humongous line, never made it inside. Had to walk out to be able to get a bite to eat.. the line to get coffee was insane. My room was next to the eye machine. I had no idea until the last day. I couldn’t understand all the noise. But the hotel is in a great convenience spot walking distance to Times Square fifth Avenue and Central Park. Making a very convenient a lot of restaurants outside the hotel. The room was always cleaned every day so that made it nice to come to a clean room. Always enough towels never having to ask for more."

"Staff friendly, rooms are clean and luxurious "

"Breakfast buffet was good, wait times can be long if you wake up late, clean room staff was nice, location is good. Lobby smells good. "

"The only good thing about this property is its location and overall cleanliness. We traveled in summer 2025 and the staff was unhelpful, if not rude. We asked to hold our luggage before check in and after check out only to find it hanging out in the lobby at some point without any supervision. There are only a couple elevators in the building and they take very long time to arrive, so if you can, book lower floors and just use the stairs to save yourself waiting full 5 minutes for a small elevator to arrive. with people checking in and out all the time, its hard to fit in one of those anyway. The rooms are tiny tiny. Yes, its new york, so its not surprising, but the bed took about 90% of the room which wasnt obvious on the photos (we had a king bed room). The room description (at least at the time) mentioned a mini fridge, which wasnt there but the staff did supply us with one, which didnt really fit into the room and we had to jump over it to get on the bed. AC was very strange too. in a few nights we spent there we couldnt figure out how to make the room not hot as hell or freezing cold, so we kept switching between the two. the bathroom didnt have a single place to put your makeup near the sink and we ended up flipping the trash bin upside down and using it as a low shelf. All and all, it is not a terrible place, but wasn't very good, even for new york. Better than Gallivant, but if you are okay with a tiny tiny room, i d recommend checking out the Pods instead. "