Search Randall's Island Cottages

"Every time my son and I left and returned, we were greeted..and it seemed genuine. It was so NICE!I asked a favor and Leann was so kind and made it happen. I also asked (when I booked) if they could do a simple birthday decor for a teen. I think the message wasn't clear because there were rose petals and butterly towels on both beds (I was with my teenage son) It was HYSTERICAL. Im sharing this story NOT to cause problems but it was a HIGHLIGHT of our stay because it was so funny. Ive shared with so many friends and it will be a story forever...We've stayed at a lot of hotels..abd NYC hotels are hit or miss. This was the best hospitality we've ever experienced..also, it was so clean..and the fridge/microwave was a HUGE plus.. Thank you for a wonderful stay..we will be back!"

"No complimentary breakfast. "

"Great location… nice boutique hotel that has been updated. Friendly staff"

"It was in a great location for getting around. They had a lovely rooftop bar."

"Beautiful hotel in a central location "

"Hotel definitely in a great area, every thing you could do is walking distance and you are right next to grand central subway. The only thing is the rooms could use a bit of a renovation as the room we stayed in didn't have a working shower drain or phone and not the cleanest."

"The staff doesn’t cooperate and they are not flexible. "

"This has become my go-to hotel of late for NYC trips. Not because it's anything fancy, but the location right next to Penn Station, Amtrak, LIRR, and the A/C/E, 1/2/3, B/D/F/M, and 7 trains is so convenient. Many pilots & flight attendants whose regular route takes them to NY stay here for this reason. The staff, and particularly the housekeeping staff, is super-friendly. The hotel itself is nice enough - plenty of large, double rooms, a nice art deco style (it was world famous in the 1930s), and history (Nikola Tesla lived his last days here) - and it's almost always reasonably priced. "

"Breakfast was good if you got there before it got busy. Then they started running out."