Search Randall's Island Cottages

"Easy late night check in"

"We had air conditioning. "

"The elevator situation was dismal as there were three small elevators serving a 44 story building. during peak usage times (i.e. midmorning near check out time) waits for an elevator exceeded 5 minutes and once on an elevator filled to capacity it continued to stop at nearly every floor extending the time to get to the ground floor. On our last day it took us well over ten minutes to go from floor 22 to the ground floor. Bathroom doors are poorly designed and do not close completely. The staff did every thing within there power to make guests happy/"

"Perfect for a weekend getaway and so close to Penn station. Art Deco vibe was awesome. "

"Spacious room. Friendly staff. "

"Peaceful and always clean 10/10"

"Room was extremely old and dirty!bedsheet stinks .room has a very bad smell. Bathroom floors were very dirty and uncleaned"

"I’ve always loved this hotel and have stayed multiple times. It’s in an awesome area of the city, close enough to everything but not in the center of the chaos. However, this last experience, we were placed next to the housekeeping service elevator and we did not sleep the entire night. We could hear every time the doors opened, closed and whenever the elevator moved. I ended up asking for a room change and it was much better but truthfully the room we were in should not be an option for guests. It was really really loud through the entire night. "

"Yes"