Search Hotels in Montauk, New York

"Absolutely gorgeous place. I would stay there again. Thanks for the ferry advise."…""Absolutely gorgeous place. I would stay there again. Thanks for the ferry advise."WWW…"

Reviewed on 28 Sep 2019

"The staff was very professional and accommodating. We were very happy with our stay!!"…""The staff was very professional and accommodating. We were very happy with our stay!!"WWW…"

Reviewed on 13 Sep 2019

"This hotel exceeded our expectations! It was a last minute reservation because we couldn't"…""This hotel exceeded our expectations! It was a last minute reservation because we couldn't"WWW…"

Reviewed on 30 Sep 2019

"Everything was excellent The place was super clean and warm when I arrived"…""Everything was excellent The place was super clean and warm when I arrived"WWW…"

Reviewed on 16 Dec 2019

"unique, stylish and intimate. Refreshments and snacks are in the lobby which closes at 10 so my only suggestion to people staying here is to bring your own water bottles"…""unique, stylish and intimate. Refreshments and snacks are in the lobby which closes at 10 so my only suggestion to people staying here is to bring your own water bottles"WWW…"

Reviewed on 4 Nov 2019

"The property is recently renovated and has a cool vibe. The room was unpretentious and comfortable like I was visiting a friends beach house. The hotel has an interesting menu for breakfast or lunch, amazing baked goods, pricey but memorable. If you don’t stay there at least go for lunch but byob. ..."…""The property is recently renovated and has a cool vibe. The room was unpretentious and comfortable like I was visiting a friends beach house. The hotel has an interesting menu for breakfast or lunch, amazing baked goods, pricey but memorable. If you don’t stay there at least go for lunch but byob. ..."WWW…"

Reviewed on 7 Oct 2019

"Liked location. Toilet kept running and we had to adjust it many times. Would return to this property next time we were in Montauk."…""Liked location. Toilet kept running and we had to adjust it many times. Would return to this property next time we were in Montauk."WWW…"

Reviewed on 26 Oct 2019

"I've been there many a time, but only got the "Full" history to the musical happenings that have took place there since the 70's. Really amazing to a musician as myself - who himself actually played there back in 2006 one summer. MB NYC 2020"…""I've been there many a time, but only got the "Full" history to the musical happenings that have took place there since the 70's. Really amazing to a musician as myself - who himself actually played there back in 2006 one summer. MB NYC 2020"WWW…"

Reviewed on 16 Jan 2020

"Great stay! Staff is very friendly and helpful, rooms were updated/clean/super cute, and food at the cafe was great. Only complaint was that we wished there were more mirrors in the room or at least a full length mirror :)"…""Great stay! Staff is very friendly and helpful, rooms were updated/clean/super cute, and food at the cafe was great. Only complaint was that we wished there were more mirrors in the room or at least a full length mirror :)"WWW…"

Reviewed on 3 Jun 2019

"The Beachcomber at Montauk is a condominium complex that rents out units to vacationers. It is not a hotel. There are, therefore, no hotel amenties like a restaurant, a lobby or any shops -- much less a desk. This was disappointing. The grounds of the property are beaitiful --with a large swimming ..."…""The Beachcomber at Montauk is a condominium complex that rents out units to vacationers. It is not a hotel. There are, therefore, no hotel amenties like a restaurant, a lobby or any shops -- much less a desk. This was disappointing. The grounds of the property are beaitiful --with a large swimming ..."WWW…"

Reviewed on 6 Dec 2019