Compare and book 4 Star hotels in Mount Melville, St. Andrews

"When the breakfast area was busy there were never quite enough tables prepared to keep up with demand. The buffet quickly ran out of items which were not replaced efficiently and without asking. On quieter days the buffet breakfast was well managed."

"Breakfast buffet was good. The service and staff were excellent "

"We stayed in a deluxe double room, which was well presented and spacious, with a luxurious deep bath, separate shower, washbasin, and toilet. The room itself was clean and comfortable, and overall gave a good first impression. When booking, the room advertised free guest WiFi; however, although the network appeared available, it would not connect or function at all. This would not have been a major issue, but we also received no 5G reception anywhere within the hotel. This may suit guests wanting to switch off and be a little “off grid,” but it is inconvenient if you still need access to emails or other phone functions. The television also had issues, with several channels not working properly and others suffering from poor reception, causing the picture to jump and flicker throughout viewing. The PIN code entry system for the doors was a nice touch and a welcome change from key cards that often need reactivating. However, we could not see an additional internal security lock on the door, which would have provided extra reassurance overnight. There was also a noticeable gap under the door, allowing light from the hallway to enter the room during the night. Guests who prefer a dark sleeping environment may find this disruptive, though it could likely be resolved with a simple draft excluder."

"Great spa and pool, lovely room and views, fantastic breakfast"

"Overall, the hotel is “very tired” and in need of substantial investment. Obviously living in past glories."

"Clean room but a little dated. End of the season so everything was running low, including staff morale- nice but wouldn’t go again "

"Stay here regularly. We booked a more expensive king bed room, was told on arrival we had the best room however when we got there the room was far from an upgraded room and looked more tired than their standard room and wasn’t a king bed in it, the staff very kindly moved us to another room which was far better however it was so hot and even with the fan supplied on all night and window opened, it was uncomfortably hot. Great hotel, but I would choose the basic room in future as the upgraded ones aren’t as nice to be honest"