Randall's Island Fishing Holidays

Room was clean, bed uncomfortable. Staff were not very friendly.

We enjoyed our stay at this Hilton location. The room was very spacious compared to other manhattan hotels. The property is I a great location, close to many attractions and food options. No excessive noise despite being in the heart of the city. The staff was great but especially the first level bag/concierge gentlemen. They were especially friendly and handled our items with care. We were also running late to our train but thanks to one gentleman’s quick service we were able to make it on time.

great time thank you

Nic place, small but nicely laid out. Great neighborhood!

Clean rooms, great continental breakfast. Was upgraded to waterfront room!!

great time thank you

We love 1Hotel. This was our fourth visit. However, this visit was different. From the loud music playing until two oclock in the morning, to the garbage left behind outside the entrance to the nightclub, the vibe was not at all what we experienced previously during our trips to Brooklyn. We sincerely hope the decision to use the upstairs floor as a nightclub is reconsidered. Being kept awake by loud music is not acceptable. Also, there was a bag of trash sitting on top of the trashcan for two days.Such a shame for this beautiful hotel. Attention to detail is what made this hotel so special.

everything was great

Front desk was excellent. Our room was out of order that we booked and they accommodated us for the inconvenience. The hotel was great. Comfortable room and free breakfast was a plus! Location was excellent. I don't remember the name of the nice woman who helped us at front but she had an accent and she was great. I think the manager on duty's name was Jeffrey both excellent say was on May 1 to May 2. My husband also left his jacket in the shuttle service and they were able to find it and will ship back to our house in Florida.

Clean room, helpful staff, loved customer service closets on each floor

Seriously the friendliest staff. Great experience all in all. We spent a lot of time working at the bar area and the gentleman that work there were beyond amazing. We even extended our stay 2 times. We come 2 times a month to NYC and definitely plan to utilize this property again.

Clean room but small

Perfect! Felt like home away from home!

Great location and room space. i would stay here next time!