Compare and book 4 Star hotels in Stock Island, Key West

"Great ocean front view, the other rooms look at the parking lot so pay the extra money for ocean view. Resort fees are ridiculous so be prepared. "

"The Blue Flamingo is a great hotel. It has a boutique feel with a nice vibe and energy. The drinks are a little bit overpriced, so happy hour is a MUST. $10 frozen drinks (Pina Colada, Daiquiris) for happy hour (compared to $16 each non happy hour price). The drinks are delicious and are served very cold in plastic cups. They have a nice amount of rum to give them a little ‘kick’. The beer selection is mostly domestic, $7 cans regular price, $5 during happy hour. The Blue Flamingo had 2 pools to choose from with 2 more at ‘sister’ properties. They play nice, clear, fun music and have very clean restrooms and facilities. Lime most resorts, you have to get up early to get a pool lounger to sit on, and the hotel was frequently out of pool towels. Small inconvenience, however. The hotel is not on or near a beach, so I highly recommend renting a golf cart from the resort and use that for trips to different beaches, Duval St. etc. Definitely get more of the Florida Keys vibe from the open air of a golf cart. Smathers beach and Fort Zachary Taylor State Park. They are not far from the resort. I would also recommend using Lyft or Uber when in the Keys, they are way less money than taxi cabs. Blue Flamingo has a complimentary shuttle, every hour, to take you to Duvall St. for shops, restaurants, and night life. Most B.F. servers were pleasant/professional, but one was kinda grumpy and seemed like we were a bother for requesting something. Front desk/maid service are very attentive! :)"

"$65 nightly service charge added at checking"

"We did not end up staying at this property. On the last day before our arrival, we were informed that we would be moved to a different hotel due to maintenance issues. This was very inconvenient, especially with such short notice. Would have appreciated earlier communication."

"great staff, great location, great property"

"I felt like I was charged for valet that I had no choice but to use, the shuttle that is referred to has limited seating so if you use their shuttle you may get left if there is not a return seat for you and it only runs every 2 hours , one pool was shut the entire time I was there. Our room was still being cleaned and we did not arrive until after 5pm. "

"Loved the hotel. Room bright and fresh. Liked the pool area and the games provided. Watching the boats come into the marina each day was fun too. The restaurant was perfect for lunch. Great service all around. The shuttle works very well. One blip when it left early and we had to wait an hour for the next one. "

"Bathroom needs to be maintained "

"The staff were all very friendly and helpful, and took time to answer questions and make sure we had what we needed. The room was smaller than what it looked like in the photos, but it was not small. There was plenty of room and the space was very clean. The breakfast, while good, was very much like your standard Hilton (Hampton Inn) buffet breakfast with servers getting your drinks for you. The pool was clean and refreshing. We loved the large selection of lounges around the pool as well as the number of palm trees. They provided just enough shade. The poolside bar was very convenient with good food choices. Prices for all food items were comparable with food all over the island. The shuttle to and from the airport was quick and easy. It showed up within minutes of us calling to say we were ready for pickup. The same can be said for our return trip to the airport. The shuttle to and from the beach was also quick and easy, but only runs every two (2) hours. Our only issue with the entire stay, and it wasn't a big one, was with the shuttle to and from downtown. The shuttles they use are on the smaller side and at almost every hour the crowd waiting for the shuttle was larger than could be accommodated. Fortunately, they had a second shuttle that they also ran which typically picked up those who couldn't fit on the first run, but this was not advertised and there was always the fear of being left downtown for another hour. Overall we had a wonderful stay!"