A lighthouse, a red-roofed building, and a wooden structure near a coastal area.
Photo by Carole Polney
Open Photo by Carole Polney

Fire Island Romantic Holidays

Book a Hotel + Flight or Car together to unlock savings

  • Plan, book, travel with confidence

  • Better together

    Save up to £750 when you book a flight and hotel together*
  • Find the right fit

    With over 300,000 hotels worldwide, it's easy to create a perfect package
  • Rest easy

    Packages with flights are ATOL protected

Top Romantic holiday packages in Fire Island

Price found within the past 48 hours. Click for updated prices.
  • 11 Jan - 17 Jan

    Sound View Greenport + Flight

    Greenport
    6 nights
    4.0 star property
    8.4/10 - Very good (768 reviews)
    Return • London (LON) - New York (JFK)
    LHR - JFK • Direct JFK - LHR • Direct
    £1,080
    £782
    per traveller
    found 21 hours ago
    Sound View Greenport
  • 11 Jan - 17 Jan

    Topping Rose House + Flight

    Bridgehampton
    6 nights
    4.5 star property
    9.0/10 - Wonderful (165 reviews)
    Return • London (LON) - New York (JFK)
    LHR - JFK • Direct JFK - LHR • Direct
    £10,940
    £6,511
    per traveller
    found 21 hours ago
    Topping Rose House
  • 11 Jan - 16 Jan

    JW Marriott Essex House New York + Flight

    Manhattan
    5 nights
    4.5 star property
    8.8/10 - Excellent (1,001 reviews)
    Return • Birmingham (BHX) - New York (JFK)
    BHX - JFK • 1 stop EWR - BHX • 1 stop
    £2,071
    £1,387
    per traveller
    found 1 day ago
    JW Marriott Essex House New York
  • 11 Jan - 17 Jan

    Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa + Flight

    Montauk
    6 nights
    4.0 star property
    8.2/10 - Very good (878 reviews)
    Return • London (LON) - New York (JFK)
    LHR - JFK • Direct JFK - LHR • Direct
    £2,015
    £1,419
    per traveller
    found 21 hours ago
    Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
  • 11 Jan - 16 Jan

    Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square + Flight

    Manhattan
    5 nights
    4.0 star property
    9.2/10 - Wonderful (4,178 reviews)
    "The staff was extremely helpful with early checkin and was happy to hold our luggage before our room was ready and after check out so we could enjoy the city. The room was clean, and the complimentary waters were nice. The buffet breakfast was definitely worth the price. We had an amazing view and delicious meal."
    Reviewed November 11, 2026
    Return • Birmingham (BHX) - New York (JFK)
    BHX - JFK • 1 stop EWR - BHX • 1 stop
    £1,449
    £1,048
    per traveller
    found 1 day ago
    Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square

Discover the most popular places to visit in Fire Island

Top Romantic Fire Island Hotels

Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

How to find a romantic Fire Island holiday

How can I find the best Fire Island vacation packages for couples?

Use our easy-to-use holiday search tools to plan your most-romantic getaway to Fire Island. Choose a hotel suite with an on-trend bathtub with a big view. Choose a stylish hire car with the top down to woo your heart. Choose candlelit cocktails on the shoreline, a horse ride by moonlight or a dolled-up night at the casino.

Can I book cheap Fire Island romantic holidays for two?

Get wallet-friendly away-from-it-all romantic accommodation at Expedia, so you have more kitty to spend on romantic activities. We have cheap romantic holidays to Fire Island that start from £782. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

What should I think about when booking a Fire Island romantic getaway?

The most romantic holidays are about building memories, about dancing and dining and keeping the spark alive. These are moments to level up the luxury – use the star filter to find the best of the best, maybe even tick the business-class flights filter to make the journey part of the adventure.

What should I look for in a luxury romantic holiday to Fire Island?

Spoil yourselves with a few luxuries on your romantic trip away. You can use our filters to add that extra touch of romance to your holiday: glamorous spas, divine private dining, exquisite room service.

Can I book a romantic hot-tub holiday in Fire Island?

What’s more romantic than a hot tub under the stars, together? Add a glass of fizz, a gorgeous view and Cupid’s arrow and you’re good. To find accommodation with bubbles, use our dedicated hot-tub filter.

How can I find romantic holidays for couples in Fire Island that are all inclusive?

Enjoying an all-inclusive holiday means you can really indulge your appetites together – with the promise of no awkward arguments about splitting the bill. Simply use our all-inclusive filter to see what romantic options are available.

Can I book a romantic trip to Fire Island with free cancellation and/or flexible dates?

Even the best laid plans fall through sometimes. Make sure you’re not caught out – using our filters to find free cancellation accommodation. Just make sure you check the all-important small print.

Why should I book my Fire Island romantic holiday with Expedia?

At Expedia, we know the not-so-secret ingredients to the perfect romantic holiday. Our handy filters help you search a huge range of options and book a holiday that gets your hearts racing.