Search Hotels Near Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre, Sayville

"Absolutely wonderful way to spend our 20th anniversary! The property was magical. We especially enjoyed the super warm pool and excellent breakfast! Zach was particularly warm and welcoming. We can’t wait to come back! Highly recommend. ❤️李💛💚💙💜"

"We had an incredible stay. Robby and Joe were so welcoming and set us up to have a fantastic time. The house is clean, modern, and perfectly equipped with everything you need. You can’t beat the location- just a few blocks from the ferry and downtown cherry grove. We enjoyed perfect sunsets on the bay and easy beach days. We wished we could’ve stayed for longer! We can’t wait to come back next year!!"

"Everything was even better than my friends or I could have expected! Just from walking in off the main road, you can easily see how secluded and private the house and pool are because of the amazing landscaping. Upon checking in, we were warmly met by the owner and promptly given a good tour of the property. Our groceries had already been delivered to the house, which made us able to get our vacation started!Twice we had quick questions for the owners, and they responded immediately and were able to come check on the house promptly when needed, too. We had absolutely no problems with the wifi—or any of the electronics—during our stay. It was awesome being able to easily connect our own music to the pool and jacuzzi speakers; it made our house our favorite place to hang on the island. There's ample storage at the house, and the washing machine, dryer, air conditioning, and dishwasher all worked seamlessly. The beds were comfortable, and the entire house was extremely clean upon check-in. All of the bathrooms were spotless, and the showers all worked well. We cooked each night at the house and we were never without the proper utensils or dishware. 10/10 stay, and we would love to come back!"

"This house is a 4B/2 bath. 1 king, 2 queens, and 1 tiny room. 2 bathrooms and each has an outdoor shower, which was great. There is a pool and hot tub. We did not love our stay. The house was not ready at 4pm check-in - we arrived to cleaners wrapping up. Other issues: [1] washer/dryer was broken so we had to use the same towels, sheets, clothes all week. We were informed of this less than 1 hour before check in. The host was not proactive—we had to demand he send someone to pick up laundry, but they were late and non-communicative [2] animals got into the house and ate our food multiple times because not all sliding doors close and the mesh screens have huge holes in them [3] the living room has no AC and traps heat making it an unbearable furnace (and forcing us to open the doors) [4] the pool has no skimmer so it was dirty all week [5] a bed room’s curtain was held up by tape and fell down easily [6] the dishwasher doesn’t clean well and the ice machine doesn’t make enough ice [7] all propane tanks were empty so we could not use the grill, and new propane was not delivered as the host promised.Overall, this VRBO is overpriced and the host should invest greater care into the place."

"Just amazing experience from start to finish!"

"This place has it all! Beautiful home, AMAZING location, and a wonderful host. When you rent this home you will be steps away from the ocean, sitting on the deck you will feel the ocean breezes, and hear the waves breaking. The home is spacious and relaxing, and you get amazing cross ventilation, feeling the gentle breezes throughout the home. The beds and all the furniture are extremely comfortable. Your host, Nick, is THE BEST! He most definitely wants you to enjoy this beach house experience. He was always responsive whenever I messaged him. A for Nick Geimer!! I would highly recommend this home!"

"We could not have hoped for better! Don was helpful and responsive to anything we needed and the house was great! "