Ratings based on 539 Verified Reviews

They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
3.8 out of 5
69% of guests recommend
4.0 Room cleanliness
3.8 Service & staff
3.9 Room comfort
3.7 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4out of 5
by A verified traveller from Midlothian, USA

Great location on beach. Close to ferry.

Posted 25-Oct-2016
Pleasantly surprised..nice hotel for value. Clean room and nice bathroom upgrades for heavy populated family vacation area. Convenient location with beach access and close to ferry.
3out of 5
by A verified traveller from US

Nice hotel.

Posted 24-Oct-2016
Hotel was nice. Check in took around 45 minutes and had to wait to see if room was ready. It was around 5 and some rooms not done. I'd recommend going elsewhere for breakfast then the one provided.
4out of 5
by A verified traveller

Great location, clean facility

Posted 24-Oct-2016
Location: Good place to stay if you are going to explore Mackinac Island, Fort Michilmackinac and St. Ignace
Great location next to the Mackinac Island ferries. Newer facility, good buffet breakfast
5out of 5
by A verified traveller from Columbia, SC

An enjoyable vacation.

Posted 21-Oct-2016
Pros: The best part of our stay at this hotel was definitely the room. We were on the third floor lake side with a balcony over looking Lake Michigan. The view was totally beautiful. Otherwise, the hotel is located next to the ferry to Mackanaw Island and is in walking distance to several good restaurants and shopping.
Cons: I can think of nothing that could make this hotel better.
3out of 5
by A verified traveller

Posted 13-Oct-2016
Pros: location
Cons: towels
Bath Towels were very rough. Front desk clerk was not very friendly at check in.
5out of 5
by A verified traveller from MI


Posted 11-Oct-2016
Pros: All staff friendly and accomodating. Room had nice darkening draperies. Within walking distance of ferries to Island.
Location: Lots of touristy shopping in Mackinaw City and tasty food restaurants. Very short distance to Mackinac Bridge.
Room had 2 bedrooms, jacuzzi and overlooked east lake view! Good breakfast.
4out of 5
by A verified traveller from Mackenaw City MI

Hamilton Select #1 on Mackenaw City Strip

Posted 10-Oct-2016
Location: The location is perfect. On the main strip in Mackenaw City. You are right at the Fort the main shops and the docks to go accross to the Island.
Hamilton Select was a clean and beautiful hotel on the main strip. The staff was great and the food was exceptional. The price was reasonable. Gets at least a 4 star in my book
4out of 5
by A verified traveller from MI

Just ok

Posted 09-Oct-2016
Location: It is close to town so you can walk to shops and restaurants, and one of the mackinaw island ferry companies are practically in the same parking lot.
We stay here all the time when we come up snowmobiling, and the rooms are always nice. But his room was Just ok. The bed was hard as a rock and the shower head screamed when you turned the water to hot. I think we stayed on the side that hasn't been updated in a while.
3out of 5
by A verified traveller from Rochester, MI

Average quality, surprise visitor

Posted 08-Oct-2016
Pros: looking out at the lake at the sunrise
Cons: Breakfast was just OK, cleanliness of hotel in general needs to be brought up a notch.
Location: Obviously, going to Mackinac Island is the thing to do, so this was just a stopping place.
This hotel was of average quality, the breakfast bar was lacking in choices, the staff was not as efficient as we would expect, and we turned on the light in the middle of the night for something and found a big bug looking down on us from the ceiling. The location of the hotel is great, and the lake was right outside of our door. The bed was comfortable and I enjoyed the in-suite jacuzzi, but didn't feel like it was really as clean as it could have been. But there are not a lot of other hotels that were available at the price.
5out of 5
by A verified traveller from Chicago, IL

Convenient location with great view

Posted 04-Oct-2016
The hotel is located at a convenient location, right by the ferry docks to Mackinac Island. We got a great deal on the hotel which included free breakfast and parking. The private beach offers a great view. The hotel itself offers several discounts for the ferries and activities on the island.