TOP Historic Hotels in South Columbus, OH for 2026

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Save instantly and earn perks with One Key
Learn about One Key
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check availability on South Columbus Historic Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Our top choices for South Columbus historic hotels

*Veteran Owned, Wi-Fi, pet friendly, playground

Lancaster

Mindy H.

includes taxes & fees

19 May - 20 May

View all properties

Top South Columbus Hotel Reviews

The Blackwell Inn and Pfahl Conference Center

10/10 Excellent

"Beautiful rooms, beautiful decor, comfortable beds, luxury."

The Plaza Hotel Columbus at Capitol Square

6/10 Okay

"We stayed for a music festival that was in town. And although I was grateful to find a place that was under $500 a night for such a busy weekend. I was underwhelmed by the overall appearance of the hotel. The outside of the building is not clearly marked and it was harder to find than normal. When you first walk in the cleanliness makes you second guess wanting to check in. With no other option, we did anyway. The redeeming qualities include their fantastic staff who were super friendly and greeted you with a smile. Both of the employees we encountered were very patient with my difficult group and were beyond helpful. Which I will admit is hard to find these days. So we were optimistic. The parking lot we parked in was close by and had indoor walking to the hotel, I was also told it was the cheapest lot in the city which was great. After a 12 hour day at the music festival, we were able to sleep fairly peacefully. The thermostat definitely wasn’t working to control the temperature however. Upon waking up in the morning, I wanted to start my day with a relaxing, hot, shower. Which, wasn’t a thing apparently. The water never reached a temperature to even fog up the mirrors. They also did not provide any shampoo or conditioner. Which, I understand would be a luxury feature to some, but when a guest only stays for one night these toiletries provided makes a big difference. Probably won’t be staying again, unless it’s the last resort even though the staff was so lovely."