Search Hotels Near Papa's Pilar Rum Distillery Hemingway Rum Company, Key West

"The staff was amazing - everyone was so friendly and even greeted us with a complimentary drink. The pool and hot tub were fantastic and the pool deck area was well kept and they even offer sunscreen. The room was comfortable for two, it was close to everything but far enough out for some peace and quiet. The little tiki bar was a fun addition. We had an amazing time and would definitely recommend!"

"Love it here. Everything you could want. A little pricey , but you get what you pay for."

"Very nice place, window AC needs updating. Larger TVs would be nice ."

"Wonderful!"

"Clean room and breakfast"

"Really interesting old property in the heart of Key West. Every room is different; evidently these cabins were housing for the workers of a cigar factory back in the day. Lovely garden pathways between the rooms, four different little swimming pools scattered around the cabins with one large "main" pool at the main courtyard/breakfast area. It felt private and intimate with foliage hedges between each of the guest quarters. We had a 2nd floor room with a little living room, tiny deck and pool out front which was really neat. Super helpful and congenial staff. It's not the most affordable place I've ever stayed, but one of the most memorable. Great location, walkable to everything in the Duval area of Key West. I'd definitely go again!"

"We enjoyed the beach-pool area with restaurant and bar adjacent. We rented bikes from next door and road to a concert at the island amphitheater. The only minor suggestion would be to change the drawer and cupboard hardware. They were really difficult to open."

"Breakfast was good"

"Lovely older inn with charm and great location to walk around Key West. Virtual staff very responsive. Pool was closed for renovation just after our arrival, although pool area is very small. Rooms are good size, however could use some refreshing. Our room had a private patio, which we did not use because it was creepy and not very clean. Suggestion to add seating area in room, ours had the space but only 1 wicker chair. With the charm of the older inn you also get thin walls 😂. Overall nice, but probably wouldn’t stay there again."