Compare and book 4 Star hotels in Jolly Harbour, Saint Mary

"This was our second visit to the hotel, and it exceeded our expectations yet again. This time we were joined by my brother and sister-in-law, which made the experience even more special. Remarkably, it was even better than our stay in 2025. The staff are truly exceptional—warm, welcoming, and consistently attentive. A special shoutout to Spice at the restaurant for outstanding service! The hotel perfectly captures the essence of a boutique stay. We especially loved the lively, international atmosphere, with many Irish and English guests—it made us feel right at home (I’m Irish!). We’re already looking forward to returning in 2026. A beautiful country, a fantastic hotel, and an incredible team all around."

"Pros: - We loved the pool and the beach - Some of the cooks were very nice - The food was great - Room cleaning every day - The place was overall clean - The band on the last night was amazing Cons: - The attitude from some of the staff was just terrible. The towel person and the guy in charge of excursions were very unnecessarily rude. The guy in charge of excursions started making such rude remarks just because we said we will think about it and get back to him. These 2 interactions really impacted our stay and we chose to go to another hotel for the remainder of our stay."

"Resort was beautiful and clean. Long wait time for shuttle around the resort. Wait time at restaurants and pizza was very long. Spa was great. Book everything you want as soon as possible when you arrive."

"Good place just wish there was someone to come around and ask you if you needed a drink poolside. It was only at the bar at night or at breakfast when you were eating"

"The staff were so nice and helpful. It’s a small resort and on the other side of the island. If you’re interested in just relaxing and doing absolutely nothing, then this is the place for you. Otherwise, you can book tours, experiences, or car rental/service at the front desk for an additional fee. This is a different all inclusive where there isn’t room service or multiple restaurants to choose from. There is one bar and one restaurant that serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner at set times. The food and drinks are good however. It kinda forces you to interact and meet others in the resort. Overall, we met wonderful people from around the world and had a peaceful vacation. "

"Cocobay was such a dream! We had an amazing time and stay at this resort. The food was wonderful, cottage was always clean and staff was friendly! Beach on property and nearby were spectacular! We can’t wait to come back soon!"

"Spacious room. Necessities available for cooking. Didn't have Kleenex! More towels would have been nice."