Search Hotels by Independent in Asian Pacific Thematic Historic District from £62

"Great service"

"Great food at the hotel restaurant. Rooms weren’t anything fancy but all we needed to be located to other things we were there to do near the water. "

"I like to stay and the pool is nice, perfectly for get away from work on weekend."

"While I thought the pet fee was high, it’s conveniently located next to a dog park. "

"Although the Bay Club is older, you would never know it. The facilities are so very well kept. The rooms are extremely spacious and the location is beautiful. The food at the restaurant was phenomenal as well. Highly recommend staying here if ever on Shelter Island. "

"Hotel has been recently remodeled. Very nice and updated. Only complaint was the lighting in bathroom was pretty dim. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Would definitely stay here again"

"Great location. Staff was very helpful"

"Outstanding in every way!"

"Bed comfy, pillows much too soft and mushy. Breakfast at fresh was delicious, staff friendly. Had dinner with a group of 15 at fresh and the mgr and staff were very accommodating with our big group."