Thimble Islands Fishing Holidays

Petty low key nice little ( big ) hotel. I like it, small environment changes like free parking since the place is always busy, they got the money to let parking slide. Have free breakfast. Bistro’s breakfast is not worth paying. Hampton Inn makes better breakfast and it’s free. Over good place

The location is perfect! The only thing that I was disappointed about is that when I made the reservation, I selected a room with a city view. We were given a room on the 5th floor with visibility that did not compare to what was advertised on the website. Other than that, everything was clean, staff very helpful, and the cost was reasonable for the number of days we stayed.

Classic upper west side beaux arts hotel.

Rooms are clean, location is good but a bit noisy.

Stayed here last year and it was exceptional. This time service just missed the mark. Tried calling front desk multiple times with little to no help. One time the call got disconnected and they didn’t even bother calling back. Front desk staff that checked us in was a little sassy and commentary not appreciated. Staff (from my experience last year) was kind courteous and very friendly. May explore other options next year.

Stayed here last year and it was exceptional. This time service just missed the mark. Tried calling front desk multiple times with little to no help. One time the call got disconnected and they didn’t even bother calling back. Front desk staff that checked us in was a little sassy and commentary not appreciated. Staff (from my experience last year) was kind courteous and very friendly. May explore other options next year.

Rooms are nice big and clean. Ambience and views are great. However, hotel can Improve on options available for breakfats

Very clean and comfortable. The room a bit tiny but very very nice. The food was amazing as well. And the location is the best. 100% recommended.

We stayed for 2 nights as a couple. The room was relatively spacious for NYC standards, very comfortable, and clean, with a great layout. We enjoyed the street view from our room, and the location is truly prime! We also loved the 24/7 rooftop access, which offers fantastic views of the city. The staff was kind and welcoming throughout our stay. We would definitely stay here again!

It was OK, very clean and decent size room. But small, esp bathroom where my knees were hitting the vanity. Not enough outlets or counter/nightstand space. No in-room amenities except over-priced mini bar. Staff was fairly apathetic.

The location is perfect! The only thing that I was disappointed about is that when I made the reservation, I selected a room with a city view. We were given a room on the 5th floor with visibility that did not compare to what was advertised on the website. Other than that, everything was clean, staff very helpful, and the cost was reasonable for the number of days we stayed.

Great stay and great staff!

Nice property great location

Over busy the hotel.