Search Tingler Island Cottages

"Received an email the day before our stay informing us that our room had been changed due to a maintenance issue. We had booked a premium room with balcony but were given a basic studio. While the location of the studio was good, right on the waterfront, the condition of the room itself was below expectation. The blind at the window was dirty and broken. The small table base was rusty with some tissue preventing it from wobbling. The kitchen was in need of an update. The bathroom was tiny. The bed was very uncomfortable and the aircon unit was extremely noisy. We were only staying 1 night so put up with it, but would not have stayed another night. The only positive was the location of the room, with a great view of a stunning sunset. But our original premium room would have offered the same. Feel very sad to have mentioned so many negatives, but was overall disappointed with the room."

"We honestly were not too impressed for the cost. The pool was broken, there were lots of ants in the loft of our unit. Not just a few but enough to where they were crawling on my child. The microwave was broken as well. On top of it there was construction going on which isn't a problem in itself but it is not a secure site. There was debris all over, glass in the site and an open sewer line. Overall wouldn't stay again"

"The office has limited hours, but the man who checked us in was nice. The room really really needed a good sweeping and cleaning. It was okay for a one-night stay, but I would not have wanted to stay here for a week. "

"The room was great. The bathroom huge, the living room the size of an oversized apartment. The best part was the balcony. We had a waterfront auite, and the balcony was incredible. A full, waparound porch style balcony that added immensely to our stay."

"It’s all about the Molton Brown. It truly elevated the entire experience and made it feel like a 5-star hotel."

"Terrific atmosphere to enjoy the Florida keys in a room that was pleasant and clean."

"Th resort itself was very impressive. Staff was very friendly, accommodating and so helpful. I would say pay attention to extra fees that the resort may hold on to, so you can plan for that, if needed. If you book through something like Expedia, call the resort ahead of time to make sure they are set with payments. There was some confusion with that as I was checking out. Other than that, highly recommend. I would definitely visit again!"

"Wonderful experience and place to experience the Keys! Spacious townhomes, super pools and a nice oceanfront view. We would definitely stay here again!"

"Staff was very friendly. Pool and bar area lots of fun and we enjoyed the live music!"