Marathon Hotel Guide - Luxury Hotels in Marathon, United States of America

Excellent stay at Tranquility Bay. The only downside was the beach. You can not swim there. Views were amazing, 3 bedroom rental was perfect.

Quiet and relaxing on this private island with few other guests. We enjoyed the included extras such as sea kayaking. It was a good contrast to our stay in Key West (of other keys) to see a different pace and aspect of the Florida Keys with close up views of mangroves, wildlife and the sea. We saw lots of birds, fish and a ~4ft nurse shark from the jetty! Our room (Sea Horse) was clean and had good facilities for the 4 of us (air con, comfortable beds, kitchen, etc). The included breakfast was basic but good enough - especially as you have your own kitchen. Although we did not snorkel, other guests we spoke to did and said they enjoyed it. Staff were polite and helpful - directing us to their favourite nearby restaurant which was definitely a great recommendation. It is also close to many attractions in Marathon and around. Could say it is a bit on expensive side for what it is, but that's the Florida Keys and great island location for you! Would stay again.

As others have said, it doesn't look like much on the outside, but this is a sweet little hotel. The rooms are a little old, but mine was SPACIOUS. There is a wonderful private beach out back where you can watch the sunset. The man at the front desk represented true island charm. He was wonderful.

If you're on a budget and traveling in the Florida Keys this is a unique experience. The floating rooms were made from old house and sail boats. Nothing fancy, they're boats docked and floating on water. They're air conditioned and have a bathroom with a shower. Right at the top of Marathon Key and not quite an hour from Key West depending on traffic. Definitely somewhere I'd like to take my kids the next time I'm in the keys.

Planned a late summer trip to fish, snorkel, site see, etc. Great location in the Keys. Very close to necessities with great options for dining! The Banana Bay staff was great! All needs and questions answered. The rooms were very, very recently renovated! Very nice! The reason for not getting an excellent rating was the mosquito presence, but that seems to be a major Florida thing now!

I arrived quite late, after midnight, but had called earlier in the day regarding the late arrival. Very fortunate that I did so, as the office is closed from 9 pm until 8 am! The staff was very helpful, and my room key and location map was placed in a lock box outside the office entrance. No problem. If you don't call, you won't have a room. Motel is in poor condition, but they are in the process of remodeling it. In spite of the rundown condition, the room was very clean and comfortable, even had a small kitchenette. The location is extremely convenient. Off the highway enough for quiet, on the road to Marathon's nicest beach, across the road from a public golf course (with restaurant and lounge). Lots of nearby restaurants, pharmacy, stores (Publix) and 'watering holes'. This is a large motel, it has a large and well maintained swimming pool with Tiki Bar. It sets on a canal, with an extensive marina. Of course one of it's main attractions is the price. Great for those on a contained budget.

The room was nice, but some amenities weren't replaced when (pepper towels, soap, etc). The beach was nasty with sea grass and not usable.

Clean friendly staff could use little more close parking

It's simple, clean, very laid back and has unparalleled views. We've now stayed twice and brought our dog with us. Perfect place to crash if you'll be enjoying all of the things the keys have to offer during the day - snorkeling, swimming, outdoor adventures, etc. Yellowtail is no frills. It's not a resort. If you're looking for that type of atmosphere...this is probably not for you.

Reasonably priced, lots of room. Great location. Make sure you know how to get into your unit as no one is available after hours.