Default HTG hotel image

Search Hotels Near Shelter Island, Beach Haven

  • Change your mind

    Book hotels with free cancellation

  • Treat yourself

    Save instantly and earn perks with One Key
    Learn about One Key

  • Be picky

    Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Tonight
1 Oct - 2 Oct
Tomorrow
2 Oct - 3 Oct
This weekend
2 Oct - 4 Oct
Next weekend
9 Oct - 11 Oct

Filter by

Star rating

Guest rating

Our top choices for Shelter Island hotels

A large, multi-story hotel with a prominent sign reading "Hotel LBI".
A multi-level interior with a central staircase, white paneling, and a hanging chandelier.
A spacious lounge area with a large screen displaying a welcome message, comfortable seating arrangements, and a decorative sailboat model.
A spacious hotel lobby with a long wooden reception desk, multiple seating areas, and a ceiling with blue lighting.

1. Hotel LBI

Hotel LBI
Ship Bottom, 6.2 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Michelle
£171
includes taxes & fees
13 Oct - 14 Oct
Hotel LBI
A hotel with a parking lot and a winding road.
A reception area with a stone wall, a Holiday Inn sign, and a reception desk.
A spacious restaurant with high ceilings, exposed brick walls, and large windows. Tables are arranged in rows, and there is a bar area visible in the background.
An outdoor seating area with wooden benches and a stone fire pit.

2. Holiday Inn Manahawkin/Long Beach Island by IHG

Holiday Inn Manahawkin/Long Beach Island by IHG
7.8 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Kurt
£128
includes taxes & fees
5 Oct - 6 Oct
Holiday Inn Manahawkin/Long Beach Island by IHG
A restaurant with wooden tables and blue and white patterned chairs, a ceiling fan, and a view of the outside.
A covered porch with a white roof, surrounded by flowering plants and a gravel pathway.
A modern kitchen with a dining table, a TV mounted on the wall, and a refrigerator.
A beach with a row of houses along the shore.

3. Surf City Hotel

Surf City Hotel
Surf City, 7.1 mi from Shelter Island
United States
David
£94
includes taxes & fees
12 Oct - 13 Oct
Surf City Hotel
A multi-story hotel with a red roof and white facade, featuring outdoor seating areas and a landscaped garden.
An outdoor patio area with wooden tables and chairs, red umbrellas, and string lights.
A wide sandy beach with footprints and a few people scattered across it.
A rustic interior with a wooden bar area, a large chandelier, and a seating arrangement.

4. Daddy O Hotel

Daddy O Hotel
Brant Beach, 4.7 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Federico
£204
includes taxes & fees
8 Oct - 9 Oct
Daddy O Hotel
A multi-story hotel with balconies, a parking area, and a view of the sunset.
A reception area with a counter, a phone, and a window with a view of a building outside.
A beach view from a covered deck with white railings and two white chairs.
A hotel room with two beds, a desk, a chair, a dresser, and a balcony with a view.

5. Drifting Sands Oceanfront Hotel

Drifting Sands Oceanfront Hotel
Ship Bottom, 6.2 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Mary Carroll
£107
includes taxes & fees
25 Oct - 26 Oct
Drifting Sands Oceanfront Hotel
A wooden bench and table on a balcony with a white railing, overlooking a beach with a clear blue sky.
A beach view with a wooden fence, a parking area, and a clear blue sky.
A room with a large window overlooking a beach and parking area.
A hotel room with a large window offering a view of the beach and ocean.

6. The Hideaway Hotel

The Hideaway Hotel
Holgate, 3.5 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Dainius
£218
includes taxes & fees
20 Oct - 21 Oct
The Hideaway Hotel
A beach with a row of large rocks along the shoreline.
A room with a large window, a table, and chairs.
A compact kitchen with a dining table, chairs, a ceiling fan, a refrigerator, and a microwave.
A swimming pool with a wooden deck and lounge chairs.

7. Sea Horse Motel

Sea Horse Motel
Brant Beach, 4.7 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Nancy
£143
includes taxes & fees
5 Oct - 6 Oct
Sea Horse Motel
A large, two-story building with a prominent tower and multiple windows, surrounded by lush greenery and a well-maintained lawn.
A spacious banquet hall with round tables and wicker chairs, large windows, and a high ceiling with a chandelier.
A golf course with a clubhouse, surrounded by dense trees and a clear sky.
A modern kitchen with a marble island, wooden bar stools, pendant lighting, and a blue door.

8. The Inn at LBI National

The Inn at LBI National
5.1 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Joe
£117
includes taxes & fees
5 Oct - 6 Oct
The Inn at LBI National
A wooden building with a sign reading "DECAYS" by the water.
A room with a wooden floor, a fireplace, a sofa, a coffee table, and a television.
A table with a bottle of champagne, two glasses, a vase with a red rose, and a bowl of strawberries.
A room with a bed, a nightstand, a green chair, a table, and a window overlooking a deck.

9. Colonial Inn

Colonial Inn
12.5 mi from Shelter Island
United States
Kevin
£137
includes taxes & fees
5 Oct - 6 Oct
Colonial Inn
View all properties

Compare popular hotels close to Shelter Island

Property
Property class
Guest rating
Breakfast included
Pool
Spa
Pet-friendly
WiFi included
A large, multi-story hotel with a prominent sign reading "Hotel LBI".
Hotel LBI
9.6
Exceptional
1,011 reviews
View
A hotel with a parking lot and a winding road.
Holiday Inn Manahawkin/Long Beach Island by IHG
9.2
Wonderful
1,001 reviews
View
A restaurant with wooden tables and blue and white patterned chairs, a ceiling fan, and a view of the outside.
Surf City Hotel
8.6
Excellent
357 reviews
View
A multi-story hotel with a red roof and white facade, featuring outdoor seating areas and a landscaped garden.
Daddy O Hotel
9.0
Wonderful
772 reviews
View
A multi-story hotel with balconies, a parking area, and a view of the sunset.
Drifting Sands Oceanfront Hotel
8.2
Very good
1,002 reviews
View

Top Shelter Island Hotel Reviews

Steps to Fantasy Island! Luxury Beach Home w/ Pool & Game Room, sleeps 18!

Steps to Fantasy Island! Luxury Beach Home w/ Pool & Game Room, sleeps 18!

10/10 Excellent
"Chose the home because it was so large, easy to spread out, modern, and it had a pool! In the end, what we really loved were the 4 porches and the game room (particularly pacman and ping pong). The weather was much less than ideal during our stay, so we utilized those spaces quite a bit and really enjoyed ourselves because of them. Would love to return again on warmer days! The location is also fantastic, especially with a big group. Can easily walk to beach, bay, shopping, restaurants, minigolf, etc. No need to get into the car at all."
kathy w. 5-night trip
Posted 8 hours ago
Steps to Fantasy Island! Luxury Beach Home w/ Pool & Game Room, sleeps 18!
7-bedroom house in charming Spray Beach with WiFi, AC. Oceanside sleeps 18

7-bedroom house in charming Spray Beach with WiFi, AC. Oceanside sleeps 18

10/10 Excellent
"Very comfortable house in excellent location. We were 8 adults and 4 children on the island during the 2026 September nor’easter so we spent all of our time in the house and still we remained friends."
Martin H. 2-night trip
Posted 23 hours ago
7-bedroom house in charming Spray Beach with WiFi, AC. Oceanside sleeps 18
CHARMING HOME IN HEART OF BEACH HAVEN LBI!

CHARMING HOME IN HEART OF BEACH HAVEN LBI!

8/10 Good
"The location was perfect and communication with Wally (the property manager) was wonderful. We had some issues with fans not working and cleanliness, but I have no doubt that the hosts will be addressing. I would definitely stay here again."
Samantha H. 3-night trip
Posted 4 days ago
CHARMING HOME IN HEART OF BEACH HAVEN LBI!
Escape to our charming waterfront beach house in Beach Haven, just steps from the shore. This 3-bedroom retreat offers stunning bay views and a cozy atmosphere for a peaceful coastal getaway. Perfect for families, your ultimate vacation awaits!!

Escape to our charming waterfront beach house in Beach Haven, just steps from the shore. This 3-bedroom retreat offers stunning bay views and a cozy atmosphere for a peaceful coastal getaway. Perfect for families, your ultimate vacation awaits!!

10/10 Excellent
"It was great!"
vin 2-night trip
Posted 10 days ago
Escape to our charming waterfront beach house in Beach Haven, just steps from the shore. This 3-bedroom retreat offers stunning bay views and a cozy atmosphere for a peaceful coastal getaway. Perfect for families, your ultimate vacation awaits!!
Classic Shore House in the Heart of Beach Haven

Classic Shore House in the Heart of Beach Haven

10/10 Excellent
"The house and location are great!"
Brett C. 3-night trip
Posted 2 weeks ago
Classic Shore House in the Heart of Beach Haven
Charming 2-bedroom cottage in delightful Beach Haven

Charming 2-bedroom cottage in delightful Beach Haven

10/10 Excellent
"Great stay!"
David C. 2-night trip
Posted 3 weeks ago
Charming 2-bedroom cottage in delightful Beach Haven
Great Location / Walk to Everything! 4BR Big Backyard

Great Location / Walk to Everything! 4BR Big Backyard

8/10 Good
"Wonderful home. Enjoyed our stay. Walked to all. Great location. Would rent again. One minor maintenance issue with the back door needed. The screen door needs repair and doesn’t close and latch shut. Our last night it was raining and the wind kept opening and the door and slamming it shut. Not pleasant but should be an easy fix."
Diane T. 3-night trip
Posted 3 weeks ago
Great Location / Walk to Everything! 4BR Big Backyard
Cottage in the heart of Beach haven!

Cottage in the heart of Beach haven!

10/10 Excellent
"We really enjoyed our stay. Location was perfect. Communication with host was great. Only downside was the beds. They felt old, hard and very uncomfortable. But otherwise it is a great little cottage."
Sherry B. 2-night trip
Posted 3 weeks ago
Cottage in the heart of Beach haven!
Beach Haven Long Beach Island

Beach Haven Long Beach Island

10/10 Excellent
"Second time staying here at the cottage. Won’t be the last."
Kate G. 4-night trip
Posted 3 weeks ago
Beach Haven Long Beach Island

Other attractions near Shelter Island

A coastal residential area with buildings near the shore and a distant bridge.

Bay Village

9.2/10 (170 reviews)
During your trip to Beach Haven, you can enjoy retail therapy at Bay Village. While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches.
See properties
A beach with waves, a sandy shore, and a sailboat in the distance.

Spray Beach

9.2/10 (110 reviews)
If a restful holiday is part of your travel plans, Spray Beach might be the perfect place to visit during your trip to Beach Haven. While you're in the area, stroll along the seaside.
See properties

Museum of New Jersey Maritime History

8.6/10 (11 reviews)
You can spend time studying the exhibits at Museum of New Jersey Maritime History during your travels in Beach Haven. Wander the beautiful beaches in this family-friendly area.
See properties

Thundering Surf Waterpark

8.6/10 (39 reviews)
Have a fun-filled day with the family at Thundering Surf Waterpark during your visit to Beach Haven. Wander the beautiful beaches in this family-friendly area.
See properties

Settler's Mill Adventure Golf

9.2/10 (17 reviews)
Enjoy a fun-filled day at Settler's Mill Adventure Golf during your visit to Beach Haven. Wander the beautiful beaches in this family-friendly area.
See properties

Fantasy Island Amusement Park

8.8/10 (167 reviews)
Have a fun-filled day with the family at Fantasy Island Amusement Park during your trip to Beach Haven. Wander the beautiful beaches in this family-friendly area.
See properties

Surflight Theatre

8.0/10 (49 reviews)
You can get tickets for a performance at Surflight Theatre during your stay in Beach Haven. Wander the beautiful beaches in this family-friendly area.
See properties

Frequently asked questions

What's the area like around Shelter Island?
Shelter Island is located in Beach Haven. Travellers love the area for its beautiful beaches. You'll find 668 hotels and other accommodations within a few miles for a convenient home base.
What's the best hotel to stay near Shelter Island?
Spray Beach Oceanfront Hotel is one of the top choices for your stay based on our traveller data, and this hotel offers a restaurant and free parking. It's located 1.6 mi (2.6 km) from Shelter Island. Another good choice is The Boulevard Hotel, located 1.6 mi (2.5 km) away.
How many hotels are there close to Shelter Island?
Expedia has 668 hotels and other accommodation options a few miles from Shelter Island.
If I need to cancel the hotel reservation for my stay near Shelter Island, will I receive a refund?
Yes! Most hotel bookings are refundable if you cancel prior to the accommodation's cancellation deadline, which is usually within 24-48 hours of your check-in date. If your reservation is non-refundable, it may still be possible to cancel it and receive a refund within 24 hours of your booking. Add dates, click "Search", then use the "fully refundable" filter to view the best deals available near Shelter Island.
What can I see and do near Shelter Island?
Museum of New Jersey Maritime History, Tuckerton Seaport & Baymen's Museum and Historic Tuckerton Seaport feature captivating exhibits. You can enjoy live performances at Surflight Theatre and the Lizzie Rose at 217. You might spend a leisurely day outdoors at Parkertown County Park and Jacques Cousteau Coastal Center.