Find hotels in Cedarville, NY from £57

"Great stay overall"

"Very nice staff, room was clean, very spacious, and comfortable. The soft surfaces, carpet, upholstery, wallpaper, could use updating for the price."

"Clean, comfortable with friendly efficient staff."

"Staff was the greatest"

"When I checked in aside from the check-in staffer, a nice young lady, there was a handyman/maintenance person beside her who was rude kept interjecting into my conversation with the young lady and he was definitely intoxicated, I could've gotten drunk off of his smell alone. This was extremely unprofessional and I was concerned for the young lady's safety as it was late in the evening. I left to a hockey game and came back and he was no longer in the lobby and there was no staff at the desk. Our room was fine, nothing special. The sofabed was uncomfortable and needed better bedding, also there children running back and forth till late. In the morning we went to get breakfast, options were great. Upon our return to the room to get our luggage I noticed that there was snow under the door and the floor was wet. We had not gone outside so it wasn't from us. I open the door amd there was a child with hands full of snow getting ready to throw it at our door again. There needs to be more monitoring of what is going on. I reported this to the front desk staff since the snow melted in to the rug area on the inside of our room. If you want a quiet place to stay I don't recommend this hotel."

"Older building, but amenities were better than expected. Breakfast was also better then expected."

"Sam was warm and very helpful! Housekeeping was friendly and generous. Pool was great for my son, breakfast omelets and sausage were a delicious surprise. Room was new and clean."

"The room was clean when enterred and iot was cleaned evert day to our complete satisfaction.There was no need for a/c as it was in the 20's and 30's, but the room was very comfortable."

"Very quaint hotel with a fascinating history dating back to 1843. Sabrina, the manager/owner was cordial and gracious in every way. She could not have been more helpful in getting us settled in. It was a wonderful experience and I would recommend it to anyone. Beautiful setting on the lake.."