Top Guest Houses in Windermere Island in 2026

Sky Beach Club

10/10 Excellent

"I highly recommend staying at Sky Beach Club to anyone visiting Eleuthera in the future. The room was clean, communication was always clear, and the staff was friendly and responsive. All around a great place to stay! "

Sea Shanty - Ocean view, Private pool, Walk to Beach, Prime Central Location.

8/10 Good

"The good: - The location in the middle of the island is ideal. The surrounding beaches are spectacular. However, access to the nearest beach requires walking through another property across the street. - There were plenty of towels and lots of beach gear provided.- The kitchenette was great for prepping small meals and snacks for the toddler in our group.- The owner was very responsive. The power went out a couple of times because of island-wide blackouts and we locked ourselves out once. We received immediate responses whenever we reached out.Room for improvement:- The pictures seem a bit dated. Though the space was clean, there is significantly more wear and weathering on all the furnishings. We also had a heavy rain during our stay and there was a puddle of water on the floor in both bedrooms. - The internet was not very reliable. And we had no cell service in the house.- While insects are expected in this setting, it would have been nice to have a zapper or swatter to get rid of flies and mosquitoes when we settled in for the night. We were covered in bites after just 3 days. There also appeared to be some sort of seasonal infestation of termites because of the rain. There were dozens of them in both rooms. It was very unnerving at night."

Private family beach bungalow - on a beautiful swimming beach

10/10 Excellent

"What a perfect place for a relaxing family vacation. Lots of room inside and out. The beach could not have been more perfect - relaxing, reading, fishing, paddle boarding and swimming.Diane was very responsive to our questions as well as her on island support, Charles.Thank you - hope to be back again soon!"

BEACHFRONT HOME AND POOL, 4BR/4 BATHROOMS

10/10 Excellent

"Fantastic!"

Oceanfront- Brand new Eleuthera house

10/10 Excellent

"Location was perfect. Property very clean. Kitchen well stocked - Both Barbara and the caretaker communicated quickly when we had questions. This will now be our go to place to stay in Eleuthera. Loved it!!"

Laughing Bird Suites

10/10 Excellent

"The room was clean and well stocked. It is across from the beach with a beautiful pool that is well maintained. I loved that it had a full size refrigerator, stove, dish washer, washer and dryer and the other items you would need in a kitchen along with a coffee maker and coffee! It is walking distance from the grocery store, some restaurants and the liquor store. We stayed another night we liked it so well. Great location for day trips to other parts of Eleuthera!"

High-end New Home - Large PRIVATE Pool, Snorkeling, Cliff Jumping, Kayaks & SUP

10/10 Excellent

"Beautiful place to stay, right on the water great for snorkeling and fishing"

Oceanfront Glass House on Private Deserted Pink Sand Beach

10/10 Excellent

"We had a wonderful stay in Barbi’s home. The house was very comfortable and the view out to the amazing beach was incredible!! We had a great time here and would certainly come back again :)"

Historic Home Directly on Windermere Beach w/Club

10/10 Excellent

"Our family of seven (2 seniors, 4 millennials and a toddler) had a wonderful time at Provender House. The layout allowed gave everyone privacy when they wanted, and the living/dining area had plenty of room for group meals, games and just spending time together. The beach was spectacular, and it was wonderful to be able to walk for miles in bare feet. Andrea gave us top-notch housekeeping service, and having a washer and dryer meant we didn't have to bring so many clothes. We enjoyed many Eleuthera restaurants, including two great meals at the Windemere Club. We would return to Provender in a heartbeat."

Number of reviews	3
Accommodation	4 Guest Houses
Lowest Price	£243
Highest Price	£243

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Windermere Island guest houses

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #4 Rock Sound

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #3 Rock Sound

Top Windermere Island Hotel Reviews

Sky Beach Club

Sea Shanty - Ocean view, Private pool, Walk to Beach, Prime Central Location.

Private family beach bungalow - on a beautiful swimming beach

BEACHFRONT HOME AND POOL, 4BR/4 BATHROOMS

Oceanfront- Brand new Eleuthera house

Laughing Bird Suites

High-end New Home - Large PRIVATE Pool, Snorkeling, Cliff Jumping, Kayaks & SUP

Oceanfront Glass House on Private Deserted Pink Sand Beach

Historic Home Directly on Windermere Beach w/Club

Find out more about Windermere Island

Windermere Island Guest Houses information

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Search Guest Houses in Windermere Island

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Windermere Island guest houses

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #4 Rock Sound

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #3 Rock Sound

Top Windermere Island Hotel Reviews

Sky Beach Club

Find out more about Windermere Island

Windermere Island Guest Houses information

Explore a world of travel with Expedia