Holidays to Saint Martin's Island

I loved the Ambience . The staff were exceptional and polite

Room was small, barely enough room for 2 people. No luggage racks. No room darkening shades. Hotel ran out of wash clothes. Room doors were not soft close (slamming closed). Not enough receptacles for charging electronics.

everything is close and access to the train the restaurant and bar was on point i would go back.

Overall I enjoyed my stay and would stay again. The room was clean except housekeeping missed vacuuming between the bed and window which was a narrow space (pretty sure there was a toenail in the corner). My room was right next to the elevators and the motor noise was loud a bit obnoxious but after the first night I made sure to keep the AC running (rather than it being on auto when it turns on/off on its own) and it drowned out that sound. Slept great the other two nights.

Location was great - VERY close to Times Square! Six friends stayed in family suite. Room with 2 beds was fairly small but most hotels I've stayed at in NY are. None of the pillows had pillow cases when we arrived and we had 4 towels for 6 people. It took 8 phone calls and a trip down to the desk in pajamas before we finally got everything we were missing and that was not until the next morning! Which meant sleeping on hotel pillows with no pillow cases. Gross! The free breakfast - they were nice enough to give us 6 coupons when the room only came with 4. Definitely expect a line at both restaurants inside the hotel. Ate at Bond 45 and our server was great! Other than her, the service was not so good. Friedman's was much better! The free breakfast had a special limited menu and did not include items on the regular menu. Bond 45 did not let us order regular menu items and pay instead, but Friedman's said we could. Other than our first night, staff was mostly friendly and helpful. Housekeeping on our floor, concierge, and security desk when you enter all were great!

The staff was very attentive. The hotel is kinda far from a subway station but you can access one by walking a few minutes. Its close to touristic stops like Hudson Yards and Times Square. The street is dark at night but is not lonely, just be careful when you come back.