Pros: Comfy and clean beds and pillows, fridge in room (microwave in dining room can be used most of the day/night), free breakfast, quiet location (We were on an upper level surrounded by other buildings), great staff - very helpful and friendly, good shower pressure, long power strip on dresser for charging devices, great location (subways, shopping, entertainment), reasonable cost
Cons: outdated overall, bathroom in serious disrepair and looks unclean, suspicious brown smudge on shower curtain, spotty wifi, very limited breakfast selections - muffins, bagels, and coffee only - and not served until 8:00, no ice bucket for ice (machine in dining area)
Overall, I might stay here again if it was a shorter trip (We were there 7 nights) and we didn't have our children with us (They don't drink coffee, and muffins and bagels got a bit old after a few days).