The good: The house is huge and has tons of room for the family to sit together or spread out. The kids loved having an upstairs loft area to themselves! All of the beds were comfortable and it was decorated nicely. Everything looked really clean too! The pool and hot tub were awesome, all of the levels were good.
The bad: The driveway is overgrown with trees and bushes so it scrapes your car going in and out (it is too small to drive around the overgrowth too). The decks are a hazard, we would not allow the kids to walk on them without shoes! They have nails sticking up on them and I almost fell through a board on the front so there is significant rot. The entrance step is old plywood that is starting to rot.
Smaller issues included the balusters in the railing going upstairs were falling out (we "fixed" one with duck tape) [this is a HUGE issue if you have toddlers], toilet paper holder in the master bathroom was broken, some of the dishes were dirty, kitchen faucet was loose and falling over (we tightened it), no good pool sticks (they are missing tips and/or warped), ice machine wouldn't dispense ice (we also fixed this), nails sticking out of the wall where décor used to be, smoke alarms missing in a few rooms.
TLDR: The house is awesome but needs some basic maintenance to be 5 stars. I feel like you could make this house amazing with a weekend of work! We fixed a few of the problems in our week stay, the house just needs some TLC.