Search Beach Resorts & Hotels in Long Island

"We had our own private cabin. Staff was very good. Shuttle service into town was great. Water taxi to beaches was so convenient."

"Wonderful "

"This was our first trip to Long Island, and it was perfect! The cottage had the most beautiful views, and we spent every evening outside watching the sun set over the water. Debbie and Phil (as well as everyone we met on the island) were extremely friendly and had great suggestions for things to do, where to eat, and places to visit. It was the perfect place to celebrate our engagement, and we will absolutely be back for the honeymoon!! Couldn’t ask for anything better! "

"This place was as advertised. We were able to rent jet skis, and keep them on location. We also got Chef, named Joe Johnson for the week. If you’re looking for a great vacation, I highly recommend this house."

"Clean and cozy"

"Owner is very responsive and helpful with local information. Close to marina. Plenty of fun toys for use. "

"The property manager Jeneice was just amazing! The place was clean and having the boat was beyond wonderful! I would book here again. There are a family of sea turtles that live here too! Definitely would recommend. "

"Everyone was great! Friendly, professional and hospitable, thank you everyone at Peace & Plenty."

"Mostly like to say it was not a place for kids, so no kids. I love kids, but it was nice to have only adults around. We have no complaints whatsoever about our stay. Staff was courteous, friendly and out of their way helpful. Ask for Mary!!!!!! "