Title: Cheap Car Hire in Shelter Island, USA - Expedia.co.uk [Shelter Island Travel Guide](https://expedia.co.uk/Shelter-Island.dx157359)[Hotels in Shelter Island](https://expedia.co.uk/Shelter-Island-Hotels.d157359.Travel-Guide-Hotels)[Flights to Shelter Island](https://expedia.co.uk/Cheap-Flights-To-Shelter-Island.d157359.Travel-Guide-Flights)[Things to do in Shelter Island](https://expedia.co.uk/Things-To-Do-In-Shelter-Island.d157359.Travel-Guide-Activities)[Shelter Island Holidays](https://expedia.co.uk/Shelter-Island.d157359.Holidays-City-Breaks) ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/bex-affinities/lodging.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1200&h=300&q=medium) # Car Rentals in Shelter Island, USA ## Search and Compare from Car Companies in Shelter Island ## Featured car rental suppliers Compare from agencies ![car supplier logos](https://forever.travel-assets.com/flex/flexmanager/images/2022/05/16/BEXUK-car-suppliers-logo-desktop.jpg) - ![protection illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__protection.svg) ### Change your mind Penalty-free cancellation on many/select car hire - ![trophy illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__trophy.svg) ### Treat yourself One Key members save 10% or more on over 1 million car hire [Learn about One Key](https://www.expedia.co.uk/welcome-one-key) - ![package illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__package.svg) ### Shop smart Compare car suppliers and package your flight, hotel, and car to save ## Top Rental Car Deals in Shelter Island \* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices. Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Compact Nissan Versa Note or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Dollar](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZR.png) #### Pick-up location 3-18 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City 11430, USA 81.64 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Nissan Versa Note](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/43/79fd35f4-a9f4-405e-a7d7-3a501dfc88c1.jpg) #### £66 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659530&olon=-73.804780&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=66.44&cvrfrr=ZR&ctrfrr=CC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22compact%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Special Wild Card Compact or larger if available or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Thrifty](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZT.png) #### Pick-up location 3-18 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City, New York 11430, USA 81.64 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Wild Card Compact or larger if available](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/45/c51b48dd-8870-4d51-8c96-7f12f1215074.jpg) #### £66 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659530&olon=-73.804770&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=65.73&cvrfrr=ZT&ctrfrr=XX&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22other%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Economy Chevrolet Spark or similar - 4 people - Unlimited mileage ![Thrifty](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZT.png) #### Pick-up location 3-18 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City, New York 11430, USA 81.64 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Chevrolet Spark](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/45/72c58f0a-a81a-48e3-befa-2ee0943c5166.jpg) #### £66 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659530&olon=-73.804770&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=65.73&cvrfrr=ZT&ctrfrr=EC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22economy%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Midsize Toyota Corolla or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Dollar](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZR.png) #### Pick-up location 3-18 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City 11430, USA 81.64 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Toyota Corolla](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/43/66993783-7008-48ae-be5b-e0280e3a6f76.jpg) #### £69 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659530&olon=-73.804780&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=69.1&cvrfrr=ZR&ctrfrr=IC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22midsize%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Full Size Chevrolet Malibu or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Thrifty](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZT.png) #### Pick-up location 3-18 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City, New York 11430, USA 81.64 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Chevrolet Malibu](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/45/5589fccc-a42b-4acc-8092-e77ea23a122e.jpg) #### £72 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659530&olon=-73.804770&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=72.47&cvrfrr=ZT&ctrfrr=FC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22fullsize%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Standard Chevrolet Cruze or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Thrifty](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZT.png) #### Pick-up location 3-18 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City, New York 11430, USA 81.64 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Chevrolet Cruze](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/45/90787807-9af7-4241-9b58-a7795543b073.jpg) #### £72 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659530&olon=-73.804770&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=72.47&cvrfrr=ZT&ctrfrr=SC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22standard%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Premium Pickup Regular Cab Ford F150 or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Alamo](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/AL.png) #### Pick-up location 308 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City, New York 11430, USA 81.61 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Ford F150](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/6/540fb0f7-9b8f-4fbc-93be-7057b591d5a3.jpg) #### £103 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659416&olon=-73.804147&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=102.55&cvrfrr=AL&ctrfrr=PP&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22pickup%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Mini Van Chrysler Pacifica or similar - 7 people - Unlimited mileage ![Dollar](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZR.png) #### Pick-up location 3-18 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City 11430, USA 81.64 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Chrysler Pacifica](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/43/9c129e79-2a68-4e58-97b3-110d1119e59c.jpg) #### £131 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.659530&olon=-73.804780&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=131.46&cvrfrr=ZR&ctrfrr=MV&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22minivan%22]) Wed, 11 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb ### Luxury Cadillac CT5 or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Avis](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZI.png) #### Pick-up location 305 Federal Cir, Jamaica, New York City, New York 11430, USA 81.62 mi from Shelter Island city centre ![Cadillac CT5](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/41/2ef8db43-bb39-4347-80f2-087b3a24fdbf.jpg) #### £195 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.660556&olon=-73.804722&date1=11/02/2026&date2=12/02/2026&pprfrr=null&tprfrr=194.8&cvrfrr=ZI&ctrfrr=LC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22luxury%22]) ### Don't see what you're looking for? See all car hire in Shelter Island [View all cars](https://expedia.co.uk/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&locn=Shelter%20Island,%20New%20York,%20United%20States%20of%20America&dpln=157359&date1=15/02/2026&date2=17/02/2026&crfrr=defaultFlex&SearchType=Place) Lowest prices found within the past 2 days. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply. ## Frequently asked questions ### How much is a rental car per day in Shelter Island? ### Can I hire a car from New London, CT (GON-Groton - New London)? ### What happens if I need to cancel my Shelter Island car reservation? ### What types of cars can I rent in Shelter Island? ### Where can I go on a road trip from Shelter Island? > - New York is roughly 90 miles from Shelter Island. Notable sights like Times Square deserve to be high on your list while you're in town. > - Located 110 miles away, Boston is also popular with wanderers. Allow time to check out Fenway Park while you're in town. It's one of the reasons people love staying a while in this buzzing city. > - Head to Franconia Notch State Park to feel grounded in nature. Pack a picnic to enjoy or just relax and unwind. From Shelter Island, it's roughly 220 miles away. ### How do I find the best car hire deals in Shelter Island with Expedia? ### How old do you have to be to rent a car in Shelter Island? ### What do you need to hire a car in Shelter Island? ### What is the cheapest car hire in Shelter Island? ### Can I hire a car for a month or longer in Shelter Island? ### Where can I find a Shelter Island hire car if I am younger than 25? ### Can I drive in Shelter Island with my current driver's license? > - Age restrictions: You must be at least 25 in many states to hire a car, although in some areas allow drivers as young as 21\. We recommend checking local regulations, as well as with the company you're hiring from before you book to understand all the terms and conditions. > - Driving limitations: Read the fine print before you slide behind the wheel so you can avoid any unnecessary fees. When hiring a car in the United States, it's usually prohibited to cross country borders into Canada or Mexico, use car ferries or traverse certain types of rugged terrain with your car hire. Please read the regulations before booking! ### Why should I rent a Shelter Island car with Expedia? ## Car Hire Information | Popular car types: | [SUV](https://www.expedia.co.uk/lp/b/car-rental/suv?rfrr=car.table.SUV), [Full Size](https://www.expedia.co.uk/lp/b/car-rental/fullsize?rfrr=car.table.FullSize), [Economy](https://www.expedia.co.uk/lp/b/car-rental/economy?rfrr=car.table.Economy) | | -------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Car suppliers available: | | | Our best deal of the day: | £66 | | Our second best deal of the day: | £69 | | Our third best deal of the day: | £72 | | From the airport to your hotel: | [Airport Transportation](https://www.expedia.co.uk/ground-transfers?rfrr=car.table.AirportTransportation) | ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/mad-service/footer/bnaBanners/BEX_Footer.jpg) ## Go further with the Expedia app Save on select hotels when you book in the app. Our app deals help you to save on trips so you can travel more and manage it all on the go. Scan the QR code with your device camera and download our app