Search Carroll Valley Cottages

"We typically stay in name brand hotels when visiting family in the Gettysburg area, but we decided to give downtown a try this trip. We did not regret it. The hotel is lovely and so, so convenient. It was great being in the center of the action! We will choose Hotel Gettysburg over the chains when we visit in future."

"Everything was nice "

"Limited breakfast menu "

"Older tourist grade inn Large clean room with adequate amenities Shower drained well but water pressure only fair Standard breakfast with waffles, eggs and sausage Very friendly and helpful staff Would definitely consider rebooking for next trip to Gettysburg"

"The room was nice and the bed was very comfortable! The bathroom was tiny and the toilet felt like it belonged in an elementary school. It’s a cool old house! Staff was nice but there seems to be a disconnect with communication between the owner and them. We got several automated messages but staff was unaware of what they said. Also, do NOT spend the extra money for the “gourmet” breakfast! It’s not great and definitely not worth the price. Go to one of the cute local places instead. Overall, good… could use some improvements!"

"The room was clean, the beds comfortable and the staff"

"Great location within walking of most everything downtown"

"Unstaffed front desk Wednesday-Thursday. Trash on floor on arrival. No in house service. Dark hallways. No ventilation in bathroom. Poor fitness center. Staff was friendly when they interacted. Breakfast marginal. AC worked fine. Disappointed for the price."

"room was clean when we arrived. There was no cleaning of room at all next day. Breakfast the hot food was cold and not much was offered. The front desk made excuse that they don't have enough staff to clean during the week."