Search Historic Hotels in Central New York State

"Had a fantastic stay in Cooperstown at this location! The house was very clean and had everything we needed. Excellent location and very easy communication with the property owner. 5/5 stars all around, will definitely be booking this house for our next visit to Cooperstown!"

"It was a very nice stay! Being in in the quiet mountains but being only 15 minutes from the fields was very convenient and pleasant!"

"Your home made our special day, even more memorable and beautiful. We couldn’t have asked for more. Everything about this home is inviting. The atmosphere is relaxing and the views were unbelievably breathtaking! There was more than enough room for both our families. The owners Amos and Sarah, were so helpful and gracious! We cannot thank you enough."

"Large house, all bedrooms had access to four separate bedrooms. This made is very convenient to accommodate four different families. Quick 8 minute ride to All Star Village. The owner was available to help with anything we needed to make the stay comfortable."

"The staff and breakfast were excellent. For areas of improvement, the road sign needs a light to illuminate it at night and the plants around it need to be trimmed to improve visibility. The landscaping on the grounds and on the porch need upkeep and improvement. It would be helpful to add a write up or plaque about the history of the home as you enter."

"Great place to stay, everyone was friendly, it was very clean "

"Remotely located on a beautiful lake a few miles from Cooperstown. Everything was very nice and clean. The staff was particularly attentive here, I would definitely recommend this lodge to friends and would stay here again."

"Nice place, nice staff … convenient location."