Pros: Location, clean, new construction
Cons: Unprofessional/inexperienced management who will contact you after-hours (phone and text) on separate days about bogus complaints from neighbors; complaining neighbors who will contact the host repeatedly regarding the noise that they hear from adjacent properties and mistakenly attribute to his property (btw, welcome to a college town!); noise from adjacent properties that will keep you awake (numerous earplugs were provided by the host); safety - both exterior doors were damaged and difficult to use (easy for break-ins!), no fire extinguisher or first aid kit inside home!; kitchen - refrigerator and freezer new but not properly functional, bring your own cooking supplies because it's poorly stocked for cooking (no foil, no wrap, a few packets of sugar, no spices, no oils, no food storage, no mixing bowls, limited serving dishes), lack of kitchen garbage bags; bath - no wash cloths, insufficient towels for all guests, no robe hooks; bed - lack of varied sleeping pillows, the only ones provided were oversized "boulders" that caused several guests discomfort and lost sleep.
I raised some of these issues with the host, for example, with the lack of garbage bags. His response was that I could go into his locker outside the property to procure them. He lives around the corner, but it was evidently too much trouble to provide extra at the beginning or to drop some off himself. And we never did see any wash cloths.
My friends and I have stayed at a multitude of vacation rentals over the years. This one stands out for the numerous uncomfortable issues that we encountered, preventing our full enjoyment of the property. We won't be back.