Search Nantucket Island Cottages

"We enjoyed our stay!"

"We had a wonderful stay at this house. It had everything we needed and our host Peter communicated well with us. The house was very clean and had plenty room for all four of us. It was a very cold spring weekend and the heat worked very fast and well in all the rooms. We loved cooking and sitting in the sunlight living room. We can't wait to visit this wonderful cottage again!"

"The perfect location for walks to downtown, Steps beach, neighborhood stroll, and exploring. House was clean, great space and quiet. We went in mid April."

"2nd time staying at this property. Wonderful “Nantucket” vibes. Decor fits the island and the property is a quick walk to town. Perfect location. Well run property. Highly recommended. Hope to be back soon. A++"

"The cottage was clean and comfortable as reported. The location is excellent, we walked to town, and all around. I would call the house a cottage as it is relatively small and the decor etc are a little dated but cute. The one draw back was that it was like 90+ degrees and there is no AC. We opened all the windows and there were plenty of window fans available and overhead fans, and while it did cool down some at night, we were still hot and there really wasn't anything to do to get some relief....

"This was clean, amazing location and super cute; however, there is a new build that is being built in front of it so you do not get the full view of the ocean as depicted in the photos."

"Great location and really cool place. Don’t tell anyone…"

"2nd stay! So happy to have been back to this house. Wonderful in every way"

"Nice property but with multiple properties onsite parking is problematical."

"Property was amazing! Better than the pictures. Location was close to wonderful restaurants and shopping as well as the ferry. Was wonderfully supplied with everything you needed! Highly recommend this property!"

"Another wonderful stay at the Cindy! Last time I booked the Cynthia which includes an extra bed (the one pictured) and bath, but it didn't really matter. The space is bright and clean with a great kitchen. Walking distance to everything in town on a quiet side street. Def recommend!"

"This cottage is close to town, very clean, with the perfect amount of amenities. It was cozy and had 4 good sized bedrooms. Fresh flowers were a special find when we arrived. We plan to go back!"

"this was our first time coming to Nantucket. The location of the cottage could not have been better. We enjoyed walking into town multiple times a day, walking to the beach, and just wandering around the surrounding neighborhood. The cottage is obviously well loved. Beautiful oil paintings and the garden was something special. If we ever find ourselves back up this way again, we will definitely stay in the same spot!"

"The cottage was very cute & nostalgic. Very close to ocean with private beach access. The owner was very attentive. Had a very relaxing time in beautiful location."

"We loved our stay at Honeysuckle Right. From the moment we walked in, we were in love with the decor, sleeping accommodations and distance to town. Exceeded our expectations! Look forward to a return stay."

"Our first visit to Nantucket was all we hoped for. The Cynthia Cottage is a lovely property; well appointed & true to the online pix. Theresa was very responsive & helpful. We’re very happy we chose this home for our visit."

"The property was neat, clean and in a fabulous location. We appreciated the little touches like the fresh flowers and the soft music playing when we arrived. Thank you!"

"My small family of 3 had such a wonderful Thanksgiving stay at this cottage. We found everything to be exactly as described and as depicted in the photos. The location was close enough to town to allow for an easy walk to shops, but also in a great jumping off spot for drives to other parts of the island. It was also super quiet. Though the bathroom was relatively small, it was very clean and functional for our needs. The kitchen had modern appliances that made meal prep easy. My 11-year old...

"Super convenient, location, quiet. The house was just the right size with all the right amenities. Very large land, fire pits and outdoor dining. We had a great stay."

"Had a wonderful stay again. Always have a good experience at these properties. Appreciate the consistency!"

"The perfect location for walks to downtown, Steps beach, neighborhood stroll, and exploring. House was clean, great space and quiet. We went in mid April."

"We enjoyed our stay!"

"We had a wonderful stay at this house. It had everything we needed and our host Peter communicated well with us. The house was very clean and had plenty room for all four of us. It was a very cold spring weekend and the heat worked very fast and well in all the rooms. We loved cooking and sitting in the sunlight living room. We can't wait to visit this wonderful cottage again!"