Find Romantic Hotels in Long Island

"Food was really good. Many options and delicious. Beautiful property. Beach not that nice but next beach over was very nice. Kayaked and also walked to beach across from property which was also very nice. Staff very friendly and took care all of our needs. "

" Great "

"The beaches were beautiful and the staff was friendly. Good options at the snack bar. Dinner options were limited but the food was good. "

"Fantastic Resort, great room with great food options for those with dietary restrictions. "

"My husband and I came here for our honeymoon in June/July 2025. We enjoyed our own private pool in our villa and the food was excellent. Our room was always constantly stocked with beverages. I would recommend this for a honeymoon destination. "

"Exceptional Service"

"It’s a beautiful property and very family friendly. There’s several dining options, pools, and tons of activities to do. It’s not necessary to leave the hotel for activities, but if you do everything is right at your fingertips from rental cars, tours, excursions you name it and it’s available to you. The employees are very hospitable and friendly. We stayed in a 2bdrm villa and loved it. Very spacious with plenty room for kids to move about. Beach is nice with plenty of chairs and shade to sit under. The only downside to the beach is seaweed, but you’re still able to swim and enjoy it. The food options were ok!!!! The buffet options were good not great and there are specialty dining options available for an additional cost. Would definitely recommend this property to anyone looking for a laid back, quiet and friendly place to vacation. "

"Had a great time. We had no issues the whole week. We are puzzled by some of the bad reviews. "

"Just checking out from the most amazing, relaxing week we’ve had. Blue Waters exceeded our expectations. The staff are incredible, always politely greeting, taking care of anything my family of 4 needed. The resort is small and so calm and relaxing"