The room itself was a nice size, and the hotel included a "free drink" coupon for the on-site bar which was a nice touch (and great bartenders!).
Overall the location was nice, but there were some reasons I didn't list 5 stars:
- Hotel parking is just municipal parking that is shared with nearby businesses and the marina, so we drove in circles for about half an hour before we were able to find a spot; once inside they indicated that paid parking was suspended by the town for now, but could be reinstated in the future
- Our reservation had to be booked through Expedia because the hotel website wasn't working, but when we arrived they indicated that because our booking didn't come through their system our room had been given away. After about an hour of triaging, they were able to find a comparable room for us to use
- The room itself was nice, but was located adjacent to the municipal parking with little noise reduction (so the bar letting out at 1 AM was right outside our window)
- The bedroom window shades fell off in the middle of the night, allowing the street lights to flood the room
Overall, my wife and I laughed off the number of inconveniences we encountered with this reservation, but I could see these having an impact on another person trying to book.