Find the best South Eleuthera Hotels

"The room was very nice and spotless.Nice Amenities,great service from everyone.I loved the stay!"

"Everything about this resort was beautiful! I am so happy we decided to book this wonderful place! it has truly been a remarkable experience! We can't wait to return! "

"Rooms were clean and comfortable. Staff was friendly. Would definitely stay again and recommend. Would recommend some signage on front road."

"Loved our stay!!! "

"Fantastic welcome and a great place!"

"The home and owner were wonderful!"

"My stay at the Pilot House was nothing but amazing. Karen, the owner, was very responsive to messages, making sure I found the place easily and providing great recommendations around the Island. The rooms are newly renovated with a luxury hotel feeling. Staying at the pilot house was above expectations. Looking forward to staying there again."

"Thoughtfully and tastefully furnished and nicely maintained. I had a nice night's sleep."

"Wonderful location (right on the beach). Also a relatively central location from which to explore Eleuthera.The home has lots of space (you don't feel cramped).Very private ...you often have the beach to yourselves.Host responds quickly to any questions or concerns (strives to please)."

"My husband and I were looking to get to know different parts of the island and this was a fabulous stop in the south. Learned a lot about the area from Karin and had a great time."

"The property was very clean and comfortable. And the host was very accommodating and responsive. "

"The home is in a beautiful beachfront location. It has nicely appointed rooms and was extremely clean. I would recommend it to friends and would stay again."

"Great stay with the family in Tarpon Bay. Hosts took great care. We will be back for sure 😊"

"host was very welcoming and great stay at there house would reccomend beautiful home and activities everywhere"

"Really enjoyed our stay. Host was exceptional. We like the remoteness yet not too far to get supplies."