Title: The Best Hotels Closest to Bay Street Theatre in Sag Harbor - 2026 Updated Prices | Expedia.co.uk [Sag Harbor Travel Guide](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor.dx154327)[Holiday Rentals in Sag Harbor](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Holiday-Rentals.d154327.Travel-Guide-HolidayRentals)[Things to do in Sag Harbor](https://expedia.co.uk/Things-To-Do-In-Sag-Harbor.d154327.Travel-Guide-Activities)[Bay Street Theatre Car Hire](https://expedia.co.uk/Compare-Cheap-Car-Hire-In-Bay-Street-Theatre.d6326787.Car-Hire-Guide)[Bay Street Theatre Holidays](https://expedia.co.uk/Bay-Street-Theatre-Sag-Harbor.d6326787.Attraction) ![Default HTG hotel image](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/fallback-images-brand/bex_lodging_v2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1200&h=500&q=medium) ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/fallback-images-brand/bex_lodging_v2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1200&h=500&q=medium) - ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__price_find.svg) ### Change your mind Book hotels with free cancellation - ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__deals.svg) ### Treat yourself Save instantly and earn perks with One Key [Learn about One Key](https://www.expedia.co.uk/welcome-one-key) - ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__bed.svg) ### Be picky Search almost a million properties worldwide ## Check prices for these dates Tonight [14 Feb - 15 Feb](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?regionId=6326787&startDate=2026-02-14&endDate=2026-02-15&adults=2&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) Tomorrow [15 Feb - 16 Feb](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?regionId=6326787&startDate=2026-02-15&endDate=2026-02-16&adults=2&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) Next weekend [20 Feb - 22 Feb](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?regionId=6326787&startDate=2026-02-20&endDate=2026-02-22&adults=2&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) In two weeks [27 Feb - 1 Mar](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?regionId=6326787&startDate=2026-02-27&endDate=2026-03-01&adults=2&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) Recommended Price (low to high) Distance Property class ## Our top choices for Bay Street Theatre hotels ![Building design](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/27000000/26500000/26497900/26497858/1c345cd0.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Lobby](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/27000000/26500000/26497900/26497858/f95ca887.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Outdoor pool](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/27000000/26500000/26497900/26497858/14a9b9bf.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Lobby lounge](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/27000000/26500000/26497900/26497858/6037fc82.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Sag Harbor Inn [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Sag-Harbor-Inn.h26497858.Hotel-Information) 0.4 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.4/10 Exceptional (582 reviews) "Lovely hotel, very clean and friendly! Definitely going back!" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Hollie £172 includes taxes & fees 15 Feb - 16 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Sag-Harbor-Inn.h26497858.Hotel-Information) ![Property entrance](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/82000000/81150000/81143200/81143153/ce84672e.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Interior detail](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/82000000/81150000/81143200/81143153/18d5c2a5.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Point of interest](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/82000000/81150000/81143200/81143153/5c1700b6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/82000000/81150000/81143200/81143153/d64f35e8.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Sagaponack [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Wainscott-Hotels-The-Wainscott-Inn.h81143153.Hotel-Information) 4.3 mi from Bay Street Theatre 8.8/10 Excellent (224 reviews) "The property and room was clean, easily accessible, and staff were very friendly. We would stay here again!" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Daren £147 includes taxes & fees 16 Mar - 17 Mar [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Wainscott-Hotels-The-Wainscott-Inn.h81143153.Hotel-Information) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/77000000/76720000/76716300/76716269/5a27472c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Terrace King | Living area | Flat-screen TV, Netflix, Hulu, streaming services](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/77000000/76720000/76716300/76716269/582203a3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Terrace King | Premium bedding, down duvets, individually decorated](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/77000000/76720000/76716300/76716269/efe41897.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Restaurant](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/77000000/76720000/76716300/76716269/7f5c2322.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Shoals Suites and Slips [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southold-Hotels-The-Shoals-Suites-And-Slips.h76716269.Hotel-Information) 7.6 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.4/10 Exceptional (240 reviews) "Great stay, will definitely go again" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) ANTONIO J £131 includes taxes & fees 22 Feb - 23 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southold-Hotels-The-Shoals-Suites-And-Slips.h76716269.Hotel-Information) ![Restaurant](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611000/12610909/ae8f0ca6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611000/12610909/c4264a32.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611000/12610909/77fe5437.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Standard Room, 1 King Bed, Bay View | Room amenity](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611000/12610909/e54c439c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### House on Chase Creek [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Shelter-Island-Heights-Hotels-House-On-Chase-Creek.h12610909.Hotel-Information) 6.3 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.4/10 Exceptional (81 reviews) " This was my husband and my first time visiting Shelter Island and I feel lucky that my stay was at the House of ChaseCreek. Bill was excellent in helping us navigate our stay on the Island which made for an enjoyable experience. The house was charming , very clean , and had easy access to the town restaurant s, and Ferry. Highly recommend ! " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Maureen £87 includes taxes & fees 23 Feb - 24 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Shelter-Island-Heights-Hotels-House-On-Chase-Creek.h12610909.Hotel-Information) ![2 restaurants, American cuisine](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/2000000/1090000/1085700/1085655/d3bf1318.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Front of property](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/2000000/1090000/1085700/1085655/44f578e9.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Reception](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/2000000/1090000/1085700/1085655/d269b9f6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Carriage House | Living area | Flat-screen TV](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/2000000/1090000/1085700/1085655/6a224301.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-The-1770-House-Restaurant-Inn.h1085655.Hotel-Information) 6.2 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.8/10 Exceptional (162 reviews) "The staff was incredibly genuine and the property felt intimate and comfortable." ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Aniya £251 includes taxes & fees 17 Feb - 18 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-The-1770-House-Restaurant-Inn.h1085655.Hotel-Information) ![View from property](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/24000000/23260000/23252100/23252049/52063f27.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Suite, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed | Premium bedding, in-room safe, iron/ironing board, free WiFi](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/24000000/23260000/23252100/23252049/7418aad9.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Free daily on-the-go breakfast ](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/24000000/23260000/23252100/23252049/ecd1e47d.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Lobby sitting area](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/24000000/23260000/23252100/23252049/338f251a.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Journey East Hampton [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-Journey-East-Hampton.h23252049.Hotel-Information) 7.4 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.2/10 Wonderful (163 reviews) "Amazing stay" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Liana £160 includes taxes & fees 19 Feb - 20 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-Journey-East-Hampton.h23252049.Hotel-Information) ![Beach bar](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/92000000/91070000/91069000/91068954/52eefc00.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Waterfront Beach Shack Studio | Premium bedding, down duvets, pillow-top beds, minibar](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/92000000/91070000/91069000/91068954/244f3d92.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Waterfront Beach Shack Studio | Premium bedding, down duvets, pillow-top beds, minibar](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/92000000/91070000/91069000/91068954/fe6e5945.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![View from room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/92000000/91070000/91069000/91068954/2d824970.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-Silver-Sands.h91068954.Hotel-Information) 7.6 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.8/10 Exceptional (144 reviews) "Everything was excellent, best hotel on the north fork. " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Dan [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-Silver-Sands.h91068954.Hotel-Information) ![Beach nearby](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35380000/35373800/35373712/e5f6999f.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35380000/35373800/35373712/2a96c58c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Garden](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35380000/35373800/35373712/98e9a1b4.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Free continental breakfast on weekends ](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35380000/35373800/35373712/062f5fd3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Huntting Inn [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-The-Huntting-Inn.h35373712.Hotel-Information) 6.3 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.0/10 Wonderful (105 reviews) "Inn has been newly renovated. Room was spotless. Staff were wonderful. Had an excellent stay. Highly recommend! " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Valerie £307 includes taxes & fees 1 Mar - 2 Mar [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-The-Huntting-Inn.h35373712.Hotel-Information) ![Graybarn Cottage | Frette Italian sheets, premium bedding, down duvets, pillow-top beds](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/3000000/2870000/2861900/2861838/dde88cf3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Graybarn Cottage | Frette Italian sheets, premium bedding, down duvets, pillow-top beds](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/3000000/2870000/2861900/2861838/d1fe07eb.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Front of property – evening/night](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/3000000/2870000/2861900/2861838/e0e0def6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Graybarn Cottage | Room amenity](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/3000000/2870000/2861900/2861838/1d639007.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Mill House Inn [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-Mill-House-Inn.h2861838.Hotel-Information) 6.3 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.0/10 Wonderful (78 reviews) "the rooms are outdated and the front desk staff was overbearing the location is great but it’s noisy the breakfast was awesome as was the chef " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Sharon £230 includes taxes & fees 17 Feb - 18 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-Mill-House-Inn.h2861838.Hotel-Information) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15630000/15622100/15622089/f2951978.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Restaurant](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15630000/15622100/15622089/942c49f5.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Bar (on property)](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15630000/15622100/15622089/a9a67717.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Private Suite, 1 King Bed, Non Smoking (Private Suite - Adults Only) | Premium bedding, minibar, iron/ironing board, bed sheets](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15630000/15622100/15622089/d6ac52f8.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Zey Hotel [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-The-Gallery-Hotel.h15622089.Hotel-Information) 7.8 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.2/10 Wonderful (296 reviews) "Quiet yet situated right in the heart of Greenport." ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Andrew £271 includes taxes & fees 17 Feb - 18 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-The-Gallery-Hotel.h15622089.Hotel-Information) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118540000/118532400/118532380/b309a772.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118540000/118532400/118532380/f417f407.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Family Studio Suite, 2 Queen Beds | Hypo-allergenic bedding, memory-foam beds, individually decorated](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118540000/118532400/118532380/e9280c9e.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118540000/118532400/118532380/a2d322f0.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Wainscott Woods Retreat [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Wainscott-Hotels-Wainscott-Woods-Retreat.h118532380.Hotel-Information) 4.4 mi from Bay Street Theatre 7.0/10 Good (9 reviews) "Newly Renovated and extremely clean, well kept, and inviting rooms. Staff could not be nicer and more accommodating. Location is ideally situated close to lots of shops, Goldbergs for bagels, East Hampton Beaches etc. Highly recommend this accommodation to anyone staying in the area." ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Ivan £239 includes taxes & fees 16 Feb - 17 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Wainscott-Hotels-Wainscott-Woods-Retreat.h118532380.Hotel-Information) ![Sun deck](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35230000/35229400/35229370/dc6eb455.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Breakfast served](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35230000/35229400/35229370/29d9fdab.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Meeting facility](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35230000/35229400/35229370/f0f56ac7.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35230000/35229400/35229370/3451f87b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Menhaden [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-The-Menhaden.h35229370.Hotel-Information) 7.7 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.6/10 Exceptional (176 reviews) "Wonderful stay in a quaint hotel..The small town was amazing and had such cozy welcoming atmosphere! " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Cory £214 includes taxes & fees 17 Feb - 18 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-The-Menhaden.h35229370.Hotel-Information) ![Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/97000000/96720000/96718100/96718085/242d28e0.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Private beach nearby, sun-loungers, beach umbrellas, beach towels](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/97000000/96720000/96718100/96718085/e94ab56a.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Seasonal outdoor pool](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/97000000/96720000/96718100/96718085/59bbc572.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Lobby sitting area](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/97000000/96720000/96718100/96718085/70895a0f.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Vine & Sand [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southold-Hotels-Vine-Sand.h96718085.Hotel-Information) 8.3 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.6/10 Exceptional (15 reviews) "Wonderful stay" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Judy [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southold-Hotels-Vine-Sand.h96718085.Hotel-Information) ![Reception](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/54000000/53970000/53963000/53962986/cc53a2c2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![1 bedroom, premium bedding, down duvets, in-room safe](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/54000000/53970000/53963000/53962986/1bfd9996.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Seasonal outdoor pool, open 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM, pool umbrellas](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/54000000/53970000/53963000/53962986/725f66be.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Seasonal outdoor pool, open 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM, pool umbrellas](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/54000000/53970000/53963000/53962986/c5b3ea42.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Bentley Hotel Southampton [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southampton-Hotels-Bentley-Southampton.h53962986.Hotel-Information) 11.6 mi from Bay Street Theatre 9.6/10 Exceptional (435 reviews) "Adorable room" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Martin £106 includes taxes & fees 20 Feb - 21 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southampton-Hotels-Bentley-Southampton.h53962986.Hotel-Information) ![Beach nearby, white sand, sun-loungers, beach umbrellas](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10550000/10547800/10547745/028711b6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Property amenity](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10550000/10547800/10547745/fa70e85b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Frette Italian sheets, premium bedding, down duvets, memory-foam beds](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10550000/10547800/10547745/a3bdf0f5.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Aerial view](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10550000/10547800/10547745/56f0c16b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Roundtree, Amagansett [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Amagansett-Hotels-The-Roundtree.h10547745.Hotel-Information) 8.2 mi from Bay Street Theatre 10/10 Exceptional (93 reviews) "Very nice property, very nice food, and very nice service. Although the room was very nice and clean there was some maintenance needed in the bathroom area" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Francisco £522 includes taxes & fees 16 Feb - 17 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Amagansett-Hotels-The-Roundtree.h10547745.Hotel-Information) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/7b5c5b88.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/w1169h650x0y0-3f68a3a3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Reception](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/w1170h1164x0y1-82df79df.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Restaurant](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/602810ce.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Rams Head Inn [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Shelter-Island-Heights-Hotels-The-Rams-Head-Inn.h89981758.Hotel-Information) 5.4 mi from Bay Street Theatre 7.6/10 Good (18 reviews) "Beautiful views and lovely service " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Lana [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Shelter-Island-Heights-Hotels-The-Rams-Head-Inn.h89981758.Hotel-Information) ![Property entrance](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/10000000/9660000/9652100/9652095/d7688cb9.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior detail](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/10000000/9660000/9652100/9652095/32e03a99.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Classic Queen | Frette Italian sheets, premium bedding, minibar, in-room safe](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/10000000/9660000/9652100/9652095/6ddcc118.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Bar (on property)](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/10000000/9660000/9652100/9652095/968c61db.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Maidstone [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-The-Maidstone.h9652095.Hotel-Information) 6.2 mi from Bay Street Theatre 8.0/10 Very good (150 reviews) "We had a wonderful stay " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Sabrina £149 includes taxes & fees 26 Feb - 27 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/East-Hampton-Hotels-The-Maidstone.h9652095.Hotel-Information) ![Resort view](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15280000/15273200/15273178/7aeccb7c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed | Frette Italian sheets, premium bedding, down duvets, pillow-top beds](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15280000/15273200/15273178/ac1b5094.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Lunch, dinner, brunch served; American cuisine, beach views ](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15280000/15273200/15273178/55b708b5.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Yoga](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15280000/15273200/15273178/a7c5a78c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Sound View Greenport [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-Sound-View-Greenport.h15273178.Hotel-Information) 8.4 mi from Bay Street Theatre 8.4/10 Very good (610 reviews) "Nice place" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Mateusz £146 includes taxes & fees 16 Mar - 17 Mar [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-Sound-View-Greenport.h15273178.Hotel-Information) ![Lobby lounge](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/44000000/43540000/43532300/43532300/2c9cc7e9.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![One Bedroom Harbor View Terrace Suite | View from room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/44000000/43540000/43532300/43532300/46cd22ca.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![View from room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/44000000/43540000/43532300/43532300/7ebc6d88.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Lobby lounge](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/44000000/43540000/43532300/43532300/717b3774.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Harbor Front Inn [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-The-Harborfront-Inn.h43532300.Hotel-Information) 7.7 mi from Bay Street Theatre 8.8/10 Excellent (566 reviews) "Lovely hotel with great location in town. Great free breakfast and wonderful staff. We will return! " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Pamela £126 includes taxes & fees 17 Feb - 18 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Greenport-Hotels-The-Harborfront-Inn.h43532300.Hotel-Information) ![Exterior detail](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7880000/7874100/7874046/2bfbb5cd.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Interior detail](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7880000/7874100/7874046/885537fe.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Deluxe Room | Living area | TV](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7880000/7874100/7874046/0fc29bdf.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7880000/7874100/7874046/w3438h2272x6y0-ee61100c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Southampton Long Island Hotel [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southampton-Hotels-Southampton-Long-Island-Hotel.h7874046.Hotel-Information) 9.6 mi from Bay Street Theatre 8.6/10 Excellent (207 reviews) "Staff was amazing. The room was very clean. I've stayed here numerous times, even on the night before my wedding as I was married in the Hamptons and I highly recommend! " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Martine £92 includes taxes & fees 15 Feb - 16 Feb [](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Southampton-Hotels-Southampton-Long-Island-Hotel.h7874046.Hotel-Information) Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply. [View all properties](https://expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?startDate=2026-02-28&endDate=2026-03-01®ionId=6326787&adults=2&sort=RECOMMENDED&openPlayBack=true) ## Compare popular hotels close to Bay Street Theatre | Property | Property class | Guest rating | Breakfast included | Pool | Spa | Pet-friendly | WiFi included | | | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------- | ------------------------- | ------------------ | ---- | --- | ------------ | ------------- | | | ![Building design](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/27000000/26500000/26497900/26497858/1c345cd0.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=900&h=675&p=1&q=medium)Sag Harbor Inn | 3.5 star property | 9.4Exceptional582 reviews | View | | | | | | | ![Property entrance](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/82000000/81150000/81143200/81143153/ce84672e.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=900&h=675&p=1&q=medium)The Sagaponack | 3.0 star property | 8.8Excellent224 reviews | View | | | | | | | ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/77000000/76720000/76716300/76716269/5a27472c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=900&h=675&p=1&q=medium)The Shoals Suites and Slips | 3.5 star property | 9.4Exceptional240 reviews | View | | | | | | | ![Restaurant](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611000/12610909/ae8f0ca6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=900&h=675&p=1&q=medium)House on Chase Creek | 2.5 star property | 9.4Exceptional81 reviews | View | | | | | | | ![2 restaurants, American cuisine](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/2000000/1090000/1085700/1085655/d3bf1318.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=900&h=675&p=1&q=medium)The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn | 4.0 star property | 9.8Exceptional162 reviews | View | | | | | | ## Top Bay Street Theatre Hotel Reviews ![Sag Harbor Inn](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/27000000/26500000/26497900/26497858/14a9b9bf_y.jpg) ### Sag Harbor Inn 10/10 Excellent "Lovely hotel, very clean and friendly! Definitely going back!" [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Sag-Harbor-Inn.h26497858.Hotel-Information) ![Seashell – Short Walk to Long Beach, Heated Pool & Best Sunsets in the Hamptons](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/77000000/76740000/76738200/76738132/218798c9_y.jpg) ### Seashell – Short Walk to Long Beach, Heated Pool & Best Sunsets in the Hamptons 10/10 Excellent "We had a wonderful fall getaway at this home. We took advantage of the bounty of the farm stands and cooked everything from Thanksgiving dinner to breakfast in the kitchen. The table was a wonderful gathering place and the cozy fireplace in the living room set the perfect vibe. We also loved the proximity to wonderful nature and beach walks and to Sag Harbor. What a beautiful spot and the hosts could not have been more wonderful - from welcome flowers on arrival to allowing us a little extra time on our last morning they truly displayed a gift of hospitality and care. " [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-The-Seashell.h76738132.Hotel-Information) ![New! Sag Harbor Village Hamptons House with Pool, Hot Tub and Private Beach](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/117000000/116490000/116483300/116483260/9b508f97_y.jpg) ### New! Sag Harbor Village Hamptons House with Pool, Hot Tub and Private Beach 10/10 Excellent "Lovely house with lots of room! Well equipped kitchen, comfortable bedrooms, and a gorgeous yard with pool and hot tub. The neighbors were super friendly and the beach is so close and so beautiful." [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-New-Sag-Harbor-Village-Hamptons-House-With-Pool.h116483260.Hotel-Information) ![Faraway Sag Harbor](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/2000000/1150000/1148900/1148848/w2881h1827x0y0-498cd175_y.jpg) ### Faraway Sag Harbor 10/10 Excellent "Parking was free and really easy. Great proximity to the main street of town—you can easily walk, but it's not too close where it gets loud at night. The front staff and cleaning team were all lovely and super helpful. We loved the coffee bar in the mornings. " [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Barons-Cove.h1148848.Hotel-Information) ![Pool/5 min walk to Beach/Restaurants/Museums- Village House w/backyard](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/54000000/53900000/53890800/53890717/754e4cf1_edited_1afd_y.jpg) ### Pool/5 min walk to Beach/Restaurants/Museums- Village House w/backyard 10/10 Excellent "We had an amazing stay at this property! The house was spotless, beautifully updated, and had everything we could possibly need. The beds were incredibly comfortable, and the bathrooms felt like a luxury spa with all the high-end amenities. The pool was perfect—clean, refreshing, and such a great place to relax.What truly set this stay apart was the attention to detail. The home was fully stocked with everything we could imagine, making it effortless to settle right in. On top of that, Ray went above and beyond—he even stopped by personally to help answer a couple of our questions and made sure we felt completely taken care of.We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and would highly recommend this property to anyone looking for a relaxing, worry-free getaway!" [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-5-Min-Walk-To-Beach-Restaurants-Museums-Village-House-With-Large-Backyard.h53890717.Hotel-Information) ![Cove View Manor of Sag Harbor](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/32000000/31850000/31840600/31840545/333835a9_y.jpg) ### Cove View Manor of Sag Harbor 10/10 Excellent "Both the property and the host Michael are exceptional! I'm a repeat guest and look forward to staying here every year. It's meticulously clean and has everything you could need!" [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Cove-View-Manor-Of-Sag-Harbor.h31840545.Hotel-Information) ![Beautiful and Spacious Vacation Home in Sag Harbor!](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/35000000/34010000/34009100/34009094/b48bc688_y.jpg) ### Beautiful and Spacious Vacation Home in Sag Harbor! 10/10 Excellent "As advertised! Spacious, nice pool, lovely kitchen. And great location: 20 minute drive to southampton beaches and few minutes into Sag Harbor." [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Beautiful-And-Spacious-Vacation-Home-In-Sag-Harbor.h34009094.Hotel-Information) ![Welcome to your Hamptons hideaway!](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/118000000/117830000/117827500/117827477/507a219d_y.jpg) ### Welcome to your Hamptons hideaway! 10/10 Excellent "Really enjoyed our stay. The house was extremely clean, the beds were comfortable, and the location was ideal. About a 10-minute walk to town, but in a very quiet neighborhood." [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Welcome-To-Your-Hamptons-Hideaway.h117827477.Hotel-Information) ![Charming 3-bedroom, 3 bath house in l Sag village, Harbor with pool, AC, WiFi](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/107000000/106420000/106419600/106419564/2b3e02bc_y.jpg) ### Charming 3-bedroom, 3 bath house in l Sag village, Harbor with pool, AC, WiFi 10/10 Excellent "It was amazing!! A beautiful rental…however as a group of young women there are no blinds, curtains or window tint( the house next to us/ connected could easily see in the kitchen and living room), none of the windows in ground level were locked and were very hard to lock, and the master bedroom door doesn’t shut all the way so we couldn’t even lock it god forbid someone did come in. Just a. few safety precautions to look into to make the stay feel more comfortable! Thank you " [](https://expedia.co.uk/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Charming-3-Bedroom.h106419564.Hotel-Information) ## Hotels near other Bay Street Theatre attractions ![Yacht in the port](https://images.trvl-media.com/place/6327316/bca0a1b2-c95e-4b5a-bb7d-ca3708a62be0.jpg) ### Sag Harbor Marine Park 4.1/5 (7 reviews) Sag Harbor Marine Park is just one of the places to see in Sag Harbor, so why not enjoy the other things to explore during your travels? While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=6327316) ![Old Whaler\'s Church](https://images.trvl-media.com/place/6064491/dbb0fe2f-8cfb-4172-8e70-3910893e3fbf.jpg) ### Old Whaler's Church Visit a historic church to meet local community members and learn about the whaling past of this Long Island village. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=6064491) ### The Style Bar You can take time to visit The Style Bar during your travels to Sag Harbor. While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=553248621532665737) ### BookHampton Enjoy an outing to BookHampton during your stay in Sag Harbor. While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=553248621532665731) ### Off the Rocker Enjoy an outing to Off the Rocker during your stay in Sag Harbor. While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=553248621532665732) ### Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum You can spend time studying the exhibits at Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum during your trip to Sag Harbor. While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=6327331) ### Havens Beach 4.1/5 (11 reviews) If a restful holiday is part of your travel plans, Havens Beach might be the perfect place to visit during your trip to Sag Harbor. While you're in the area, stroll along the waterfront. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=6326903) ### St. David AME Zion Church Find out about the history of Sag Harbor when you take a trip to St. David AME Zion Church. While you're in the area, stroll along the waterfront. [See properties](https://www.expedia.co.uk/Hotel-Search?rfrrid=TG.LP..PointOfInterests®ionId=658954543747792896) ## Frequently asked questions ### What's the area like around Bay Street Theatre? ### What's the best hotel to stay near Bay Street Theatre? ### How many hotels should I expect to find near Bay Street Theatre? ### If I need to cancel the hotel reservation for my stay near Bay Street Theatre, will I receive a refund? ### What can I see and do near Bay Street Theatre?