Location: Matecumbe, 1.9 mi from Theater of the Sea
Guest rating: 9.6/10 (Exceptional, 83 reviews)
Price: £609, includes taxes & fees, 30 Nov - 1 Dec, for Our top choices for Theater of the Sea hotels
Review: We had an AMAZING stay! The staff was wonderful, providing excellent customer service and providing local recommendations for activities and dining. The property is pristine and gorgeous. My only critique would be a lack of on property food options. We will definitely be back., by Catherine
Price: £205, includes taxes & fees, 19 Nov - 20 Nov, for Our top choices for Theater of the Sea hotels
Review: Had a very enjoyable stay at Hemingway House. The place was spotless! All staff were very friendly and helpful. Would highly recommend staying here!, by Diane
Location: Matecumbe, 3.5 mi from Theater of the Sea
Guest rating: 9/10 (Wonderful, 468 reviews)
Price: £272, includes taxes & fees, 1 Dec - 2 Dec, for Our top choices for Theater of the Sea hotels
Review: Had a blast in the keys! This property gave us every reason to stay on property! Fishing provided! Bait provided! Games, bikes, excellent staff and the vibes are worth every booking moment! Definitely coming back! FYI: we stay in the townhomes and still had access to all of the amenities! Book your stay! Let’s go!, by Brian
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Trace one of the world’s most astonishing watersports back through the centuries to see some of the first diving suits as you explore this interactive museum, featuring the world's largest international collection of diving artifacts.
After visiting Hog Heaven, make a plan to see the other sights and activities in Islamorada. Discover the beautiful sunsets in this relaxing area or enjoy its fishing spots.
You can browse for the perfect souvenirs at Rain Barrel Village during your trip to Islamorada. Take in the entertainment choices and beautiful sunsets in this relaxing area.
Why not spend a lazy afternoon at beach near Seabreeze Trailer Park during your trip to Islamorada? Wander the seaside or discover the beautiful sunsets in this relaxing area.
Enjoy the beautiful sunsets and explore Islamorada County Park, a lovely green space in Islamorada. Discover the seafood restaurants and entertainment choices in this family-friendly area.
Address: 243 Treasure Harbor Dr, Islamorada, FL, 33036, US
Location: Islamorada
Star rating: 2.5/5
Guest rating: 9.6/10 (280 reviews)
Review: Brilliant excellent location on the sea front . April was fantastic and helpful. Totally spotless and beautifully updated apartment., by Tracey, 3 February 2026, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: What a fantastic time we had at The Islands of Islamorada. The resort is maintained to the highest standards while having a laid back, traditional Keys vibe. Staff stay in background but are always there to help and assist if needed. Can't recommend highly enough - although in truth I'd rather not too many people get to know about the Islands, just in case it gets too busy to book!, by kenneth, 30 June 2022, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: We originally booked Kona Kai for one night but we loved it so much we stayed for three nights. Kathryn and Zee, the office staff, were both a pure delight and very helpful. The room we had was like a small apartment and very well equipped. Nice private beach with kayaks, paddle boards and iguanas provided. There is a fairly decent restaurant across the road but it would be great if Kona Kai had a restaurant or bar too. We would definitely stay here again., by Gino, 27 November 2023, rated 10/10 Excellent
Address: 198 Harborview Drive, Tavernier, FL, 33070, US
Location: Tavernier
Star rating: 3/5
Guest rating: 9.6/10 (561 reviews)
Review: Loved everything about our stay. Unfortunately we only stayed one night but would have spent a month here if we could. We arrived on Halloween and received a trick or treat bag full of goodies and a rum cocktail as a welcome. The lady who checked us in was excellent. So friendly and helpful. We can't praise her enough. Our room was very clean, and very tastefully decorated in a beach hut style. We loved it. We took out the kayaks and paddle boards which was a lot of fun. The beach area and..., by Anonymous traveller, 2 November 2019, rated 10/10 Excellent
Address: 160 Sterling Rd, Tavernier, FL, 33070, US
Location: Tavernier
Star rating: 3/5
Guest rating: 9.4/10 (837 reviews)
Review: Great stay, our second time at the resort. Very chilled atmosphere, attentive staff and a wonderful location. Stayed in the same room as last time #14 which has been updated since last year. Comfortable room with a very efficient if slightly noisy air conditioner. We will be returning again., by Dave, 8 May 2019, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: We spent 3 fab nights at Cheeca Lodge and we had a great time. Only problem with such a lovely resort is that you don’t want to go and explore the islands (although we did) and to do so means not using the ample facilities enough. The beach and pier area was beautiful and peaceful, the gym was just about right and the room was ideally sized. We heard one lady moaning about their TV not working so we checked and ours wasn’t either - so if you want to stay in your room and watch tv…!! We..., by Jason, 6 February 2025, rated 10/10 Excellent
Address: 82216 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL, 33036, US
Location: Matecumbe
Star rating: 2.5/5
Guest rating: 9.2/10 (1004 reviews)
Review: Nice, cool lodge, but the beautiful location on Florida Bay is the real prize here. Why go out when youve got this view on your doorstep? Best seats in the house!!, by Andrew, 29 October 2023, rated 10/10 Excellent
Address: 82200 overseas HWY, Islamorada, FL, 33036, US
Location: Matecumbe
Star rating: 3.5/5
Guest rating: 9.2/10 (467 reviews)
Review: Everything about our stay was perfect, the beautiful hotel and gardens, the helpful and friendly staff and our lovely room. Just wished we'd stayed longer!!, by fran, 23 June 2016, rated 10/10 Excellent
Address: 84001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL, 33036, US
Location: Islamorada
Star rating: 4/5
Guest rating: 9/10 (314 reviews)
Review: The resort, staff and facilities are excellent. The location in Islamorada is great either for a few days in the keys or as a stopping point to or from Key West. We didn’t get time to use all of the facilities but there are restaurants on site, kayaks, pools, a lively beach and breakfast so you don’t have to leave if you don’t want to., by Deborah, 10 May 2026, rated 10/10 Excellent
Address: 84801 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL, 33036, US
Location: Islamorada
Star rating: 3/5
Guest rating: 9/10 (309 reviews)
Review: A stunning resort inspired by the charm of the “Old Keys.” The manager at reception was exceptionally friendly, and breakfast is conveniently included in the room rate. The property has so much to offer that it’s best enjoyed with a stay longer than just one or two days. Highly recommended for a relaxing getaway., by Beat, 2 March 2026, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: We stayed in Orchid Cottage which is set in its own garden and beach area. The cottage was incredibly clean with the best equipped kitchen we have come across. It was extremely private and peaceful with lovely views across the ocean. We could even fish off our own dock in the evenings. The staff at the resort were all very friendly and helpful with special thanks to Jacob (Assistant Manager) and Chris who worked behind the bar and took us out on his boat for half a day's fishing (highly..., by Richard, 12 October 2014, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: When we arrived the check in was very friendly. We stayed in the Hideaway, a little place tucked away. It was a lovely little room. All accommodations are close to the private beach where there were a few sun loungers to watch the sunset and free paddle boards and kayaks. The decorative animals scattered around the place just add to its quirkiness., by Tracy, 27 July 2022, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: We had a lovely stay at Lime Tree Bay! We even decided to book on an extra night as we loved it there, they have free use of paddle boards and kayaks and the location mid way down the keys is perfect., by Chelsea, 24 January 2025, rated 10/10 Excellent
Address: 81450 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL, 33036, US
Location: Matecumbe
Star rating: 3.5/5
Guest rating: 9/10 (468 reviews)
Review: We stayed here on our trip to the Keys. I can't fault anything about this place. The townhouse was great, very clean and well equipped. There is a full bathroom upstairs and a toilet and washbasin downstairs off the kitchen. We didn't cook but there is a full oven and dishwasher. On the landing upstairs is a washer and dryer. There were washing products provided. The bathroom had very nice complimentary toiletries. The pool and beach area are beautiful and the view over the bay was fantastic. I..., by seedy56, 13 September 2013, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: Once you get through the gate the setting is absolutely breathtaking. Such a relaxing environment. Sunset was amazing. We was also very privileged to see a manatee feeding at the waters edge of the property at sunrise., by Zoe, 5 October 2019, rated 10/10 Excellent
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated hotels near Theater of the Sea?
Finding the perfect stay near Theater of the Sea is essential for an unforgettable experience in Islamorada, especially when looking for top-rated hotels with stunning views.
The Caribbean Resort The Caribbean Resort is a charming 3.5-star hotel located just 4.8 km from Theater of the Sea, with an impressive review rating of 10. Guests can enjoy a variety of amenities including an outdoor pool, hot tub, and a beautiful terrace. The hotel features ocean views and is equipped with a full kitchen in each room, allowing for a convenient stay. With water sports equipment available and direct access to the waterfront, it's an ideal choice for those looking to explore the stunning surroundings.
Steps Away from the Beach | Spacious 1BR Suite w/ Kitchenette This spacious one-bedroom suite is just 7.1 km from Theater of the Sea and offers a perfect blend of comfort and convenience, rated 10 by travellers. Guests can relax at the shared pool or enjoy the nearby beach, which provides breathtaking ocean views. The suite comes with a kitchenette, making it ideal for those who prefer to prepare their own meals. With an excellent location close to shopping and water activities, this hotel is a fantastic option for a memorable getaway.
Oceanfront 2bedroom home with sweeping ocean views! Located just 4.3 km from Theater of the Sea, this stunning oceanfront 2-bedroom home has a perfect review rating of 10. Featuring sweeping ocean views and a private patio, it offers an inviting atmosphere for relaxation. Guests have access to a pool, and the hotel is designed for comfort with ample parking and modern amenities. This unique home is perfect for travellers seeking an extraordinary experience with the beauty of the ocean at their doorstep.
What hotels are within walking distance to Theater of the Sea?
Discover top-rated hotels just a stroll away from Theater of the Sea, perfect for an unforgettable trip to Islamorada.
The Ocean View Inn & Pub The Ocean View Inn & Pub offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, located just a minute's walk from Theater of the Sea. With an impressive review rating of 9.8, travellers appreciate the daily housekeeping and accessibility features of the outdoor pool. Guests can relax on the patio, enjoy free toiletries, and take advantage of convenient amenities like microwaves and free uncovered self-parking.
Three Waters Resort and Marina, Islamorada, a Tribute Portfolio Resort Three Waters Resort and Marina is a charming 3.5-star resort located a leisurely 14-minute walk from Theater of the Sea. Rated 9.0 by travellers, this resort features a stunning terrace, an outdoor heated pool, and a beach bar, offering travellers a delightful seaside experience. With amenities like a kitchenette, water sports equipment, and boat tours, it perfectly caters to those looking to explore the nearby waters.
Drop Anchor Drop Anchor is a cozy 3-star hotel just a 7-minute walk from Theater of the Sea, rated 8.8 by travellers. This hotel boasts ocean views from many rooms and features a refreshing outdoor pool. Guests can enjoy amenities such as kitchenettes, a spacious patio, and direct access to a private beach, enhancing their stay in the beautiful surroundings of Islamorada.
How much is a hotel near Theater of the Sea?
Staying near Theater of the Sea is a treat, with plenty of hotels from £93 offering incredible amenities. If you're leaning toward a little luxury, prices can rise, especially in peak season. Be sure to book in advance to enjoy more options and potentially better rates, especially if you're planning a trip during weekends or around public holidays.
What are the most popular family-friendly hotels near Theater of the Sea?
Discover the best family-friendly hotels near Theater of the Sea that promise a delightful stay for travellers of all ages.
Cheeca Lodge & Spa Cheeca Lodge & Spa is a 5-star resort located just 4.7 km from Theater of the Sea, an impressive 9.0 travellers' rating. This family-friendly haven features a supervised children’s club, beach toys, and a playground, ensuring that younger travellers are entertained. Additional amenities include a full-service spa, an outdoor pool, and on-site dining options with kids' meals, making it an ideal choice for families seeking comfort and fun.
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina Fisher Inn Resort & Marina is a charming 3.5-star hotel situated only a 5-minute walk from Theater of the Sea, with a solid review rating of 8.0. This family-friendly resort offers essential amenities like a heated outdoor pool and complimentary breakfast. With kitchenettes and children’s toys available, it caters well to families looking for a cozy and convenient stay.
Hadley Resort and Marina Hadley Resort and Marina is a welcoming 3.5-star hotel located just 3.2 km from Theater of the Sea, featuring a review rating of 7.8. Families will appreciate the connecting rooms and playground, alongside a variety of water sports available nearby. With a beautiful outdoor pool and complimentary breakfast, this resort provides a relaxed atmosphere perfect for family vacations.
Are there any 5-star hotels near Theater of the Sea?
Discover the ultimate 5-star experience near Theater of the Sea, where comfort meets luxury and top-rated amenities await your arrival.
Cheeca Lodge & Spa Cheeca Lodge & Spa is a luxurious 5-star retreat just 4.7 km from Theater of the Sea, with a stellar review rating of 9.0. This stunning hotel offers travellers an array of amenities that enhance their stay, including a full-service spa, outdoor pools with cabanas, and a beachfront restaurant with ocean views. Guests can indulge in various treatments at the spa, enjoy complimentary bicycles for exploring, or relax with a hot stone massage. With its elegant design and focus on traveler satisfaction, Cheeca Lodge & Spa provides a truly memorable experience in Islamorada.
Which hotels near Theater of the Sea offer the best views?
Discover the best hotels with stunning views near Theater of the Sea, perfect for an unforgettable stay in Islamorada.
Cheeca Lodge & Spa Cheeca Lodge & Spa is a luxurious 5-star retreat located just 4.7 km from Theater of the Sea, rated 9.0 by travellers. Guests can indulge in breathtaking ocean views from the beach and enjoy exclusive amenities like a full-service spa, hot tubs, and a private beach. The on-site beachfront restaurant offers a delightful dining experience, while the poolside bar and cabanas provide a relaxing atmosphere to unwind.
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina Fisher Inn Resort & Marina is a charming 3.5-star hotel located only a 5-minute walk from Theater of the Sea, a review rating of 8.0 by travellers. This resort features ocean views and convenient amenities such as a heated outdoor pool, complimentary breakfast, and a private beach area. Guests can enjoy kayaking and windsurfing, making it an excellent choice for adventure enthusiasts.
Hadley Resort and Marina Hadley Resort and Marina is a cozy 3.5-star hotel situated just 3.2 km from Theater of the Sea, with a traveler rating of 7.8. This waterfront resort offers stunning ocean views and features amenities like an outdoor pool, complimentary breakfast, and easy access to various water sports. Guests can relax on their furnished balcony or patio while enjoying the serene surroundings.
What are the best affordable hotels near Theater of the Sea?
Finding an affordable stay near Theater of the Sea can make your trip to Islamorada even more enjoyable, especially with options that feature stunning views and family-friendly amenities.
Steps Away from the Beach | Spacious 1BR Suite w/ Kitchenette Steps Away from the Beach | Spacious 1BR Suite w/ Kitchenette is a delightful choice for families looking for spacious rooms just 7.1 km from Theater of the Sea. With a perfect travellers' rating of 10, this suite features a kitchenette for your convenience, allowing for easy meal prep during your stay. Guests will appreciate the shared pool and the nearby beach, perfect for sun-soaked days. Additional amenities include WiFi, parking, and access to kayaking and shopping nearby.
The Ocean View Inn & Pub The Ocean View Inn & Pub is ideally located just a minute's walk from Theater of the Sea, making it a top pick for travellers with a 9.8 review rating. This charming inn offers accessible outdoor pools and cozy patios for travellers to unwind. With complimentary WiFi and free self-parking, it combines comfort with affordability, making it perfect for families. The inn also provides daily housekeeping to ensure a pleasant stay.
Oceanfront 2bedroom home with sweeping ocean views! For those seeking breathtaking ocean views, the Oceanfront 2bedroom home with sweeping ocean views! is just 4.3 km from Theater of the Sea and offers an exceptional travellers' rating of 10. This inviting home features a lovely patio, perfect for enjoying the scenery. Guests can also relax by the pool after a day of exploration. Onsite parking adds convenience, making it easier for families to come and go with ease.
Are there any hotels with pools close to Theater of the Sea?
Looking for a refreshing hotel with a pool close to Theater of the Sea? Here's a selection of top-rated properties that offer a perfect blend of comfort and aquatic fun for families and travellers alike.
Cheeca Lodge & Spa Cheeca Lodge & Spa is a luxurious 5-star hotel situated 4.7 km from Theater of the Sea, rated by travellers with an impressive 9.0. This upscale resort offers travellers an outdoor pool with cabanas and a poolside bar, providing a serene oasis for relaxation. Additional amenities include a full-service spa, beachfront dining, and complimentary bicycles for exploring the scenic surroundings, making it an ideal choice for families and those seeking a premium experience.
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina Fisher Inn Resort & Marina is a delightful 3.5-star hotel located just a 5-minute walk from Theater of the Sea, a review rating of 8.0. This family-friendly resort features a heated outdoor pool with sun loungers and umbrellas, perfect for relaxation after a day of adventure. Guests can enjoy amenities like free daily breakfast, kayaking onsite, and a beautiful terrace with ocean views, making it a great spot for families and water enthusiasts.
Islander Resort Islander Resort, a charming 4-star hotel located 4.5 km from Theater of the Sea, has earned a remarkable review rating of 9.2. This family-friendly resort features an outdoor pool with cabanas and a poolside bar, creating a relaxing atmosphere for all ages. Guests can also enjoy beachfront access, complimentary beach towels, and various water sports activities, ensuring a fun-filled stay for families and travellers seeking adventure.
What are the best pet-friendly hotels near Theater of the Sea?
For those looking for top-rated pet-friendly hotels near Theater of the Sea, Islamorada offers some wonderful options that welcome furry friends with open arms.
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina Fisher Inn Resort & Marina is a charming 3.5-star hotel located just a 5-minute walk from Theater of the Sea. With a review rating of 8.0, this pet-friendly resort allows dogs and offers amenities like pet-friendly rooms, outdoor heated pool, and complimentary breakfast. Guests can also enjoy water sports, including kayaking and snorkeling, making it a perfect spot for both you and your pet to unwind.
Islander Bayside Villas and Boatslips Islander Bayside Villas and Boatslips has a welcoming atmosphere for pets, just 5.6 km from Theater of the Sea, with a great traveler rating score of 8.8. This 3.5-star hotel features pet-friendly accommodations, an outdoor pool, and convenient access to nearby boat tours and snorkeling activities. Guests can also revel in the beautiful waterfront views and spacious villas equipped with kitchens, perfect for family stays.
Sands of Islamorada Sands of Islamorada, rated 8.8 by travellers, is a delightful retreat located 7.4 km from Theater of the Sea. This hotel welcomes pets, providing food and water bowls for your furry companions. Guests can enjoy a relaxing outdoor pool, beach access, and well-equipped kitchenettes in the rooms, ensuring a comfortable stay for everyone in the family.
Can I book a fully refundable hotel close to Theater of the Sea?
Most bookings on Expedia are refundable if canceled within 24-48 hours of arrival, though this depends on the hotel's individual cancellation policy, which you should check in your booking confirmation. If free cancellation is available, you can cancel directly through your Expedia account by going to "My Trips" and selecting your reservation. To find fully refundable hotel options, simply enter “Theater of the Sea”, set your travel dates, and use the “Fully refundable” filter under “Deals & Discounts” on the results page. Alternatively, explore deals with free cancellation options on Expedia.