Find hotels in Whitman, NY from £63

"Great property out group really enjoyed it! Our host Scott was super attentive and responsive and always ready to help out! Highly recommend "

"yes we enjoyed the pool and hot tub especially with the cold weather"

"The room was exceptionally clean, the young lady working the front desk was very friendly and courteous."

"Our cabin was spotlessly clean, welcoming and warm. (We were in the midst of a snow storm, where over 8 inches accumulated.) The host was easily accessible to answer any questions we had. Kitchen was fully stocked with cooking and serving pieces. Had an amazing time with family! 5 stars!!!!!!"

"Candi the local manager was outstanding. She was very hospitable and helped out with a propane issue. The property itself was very cozy but could use some upgrades and deep cleaning of the stove and appliances. None of those are something to be overly concerned about about. Just a honest suggestion. Owner did answer all my questions promptly. "

"Rooms are great, owners are great,repeat guest."

"Enjoyed our stay. This is our second time here. "

"It's hard to review this house because despite the many negatives, my family loved it. There are 17 of us ranging from 4-66. We have been vacationing together for 15yr in various states and landscapes (beaches, lakes, countryside). This is an old house in need of many repairs. The kitchen ceiling by the fridge dripped every now and then, the plaster in the living room ceiling had an area that crumbled onto the floor every day. The house is packed with stuff! China, crystal, pictures, books, lamps, and misc items. There are cobwebs filled with bugs in kitchen, surfaces that haven't been wiped off in many weeks. There are 2 fridges, both dirty as well as the ovens. When I wiped up some spilled water on kitchen floor, it was clear the floors have not been mopped in a long time. That being said, the house is huge! So much room for us all. The bathrooms were clean. Pool is old but big and clean enough. We had such fun being able to play volleyball, kickball, cornhole outside. The view is breathtaking. Keep in mind there is no A/C but lots of fans. The charm of the house and the grounds is what made us love our stay. It would have been great if the porches had the screens put back on and if so many of the windows and patio doors were not screwed closed, we could have used the breeze."

"The cabin looked as if it has had some nice updates inside with laminate flooring, carpeting and paint as well as newer kitchen area. It was decorated very nicely and was clean and comfortable. However, it is still a cabin in the country and retains its rustic feel. We spent most of the time at All Star Village which was about a 30 minute drive through beautiful rolling countryside and charming villages. If we had a booked for another day or 2, we would have been able to enjoy the deck, the fire pit and the yard!"