Ratings based on 171 Verified Reviews

They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.6 out of 5
100% of guests recommend
4.8 Room cleanliness
4.6 Service & staff
4.6 Room comfort
4.7 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
5out of 5
by A verified traveller from Lakewood, CO

Wonderful historic hotel with great staff!

Posted 25-Jul-2016
Pros: The Chop House and service there. The rooftop bar. Great service abounds here.
Cons: Nothing.
Location: Great central downtown location. Lots of shops, restaurants, the gondola, the bookstore.
We stayed only one night at the New Sheridan but ended up eating at the Chop House and having drinks on the rooftop bar. Everything was excellent. The room was lovely and the meal and service were top notch. We had a smaller room but it was well appointed with robes, a swamp cooler, ceiling fan, etc. It was quiet as well.
5out of 5
by A verified traveller from Manhattan Beach, CA

Historic Hotel in the Center of Telluride

Posted 12-Feb-2016
Pros: I liked everything about this hotel but most of all I liked the location.
Location: The location in the center of Telluride is an easy walk to sports rental shops and the lift/gondola. Just outside the hotel restaurants abound.
Historic hotel but rooms have been remodeled with comfortable and modern features. The historic aspect has not been lost with furnishings that blend with the building.
5out of 5
by A verified traveller

This traveller left a rating score only Posted 09-Feb-2016 on Hotels
5out of 5
by Jack from New york City

Jack's view of the New Sheridan Telluride

Posted 20-Jan-2016 on Hotels
Really charming and fun. Service and staff were great. Hotel restaurant and bar are fantastic!
1out of 5
by Steven from Pagosa springs

don't go

Posted 16-Dec-2015 on Hotels
Terrible food, and no parking
5out of 5
by Not Provided

This traveller left a rating score only Posted 13-Dec-2015 on Hotels
5out of 5
by Lesley B.

Great hotel!

Posted 08-Dec-2015 on Orbitz
My husband and I stayed in this hotel for our anniversary. Clean, cozy, quiet room, perfect location, staff was very helpful and friendly. We are planning to stay again next year!
3out of 5
by Penny from Chicagoland

Beware what room you get

Posted 14-Oct-2015 on Hotels
I liked the hotel and loved the location. Unfortunately, the room which was fairly expensive was on top of a bar that stayed open until 2 am complete with a boom, boom, boom vibe. A white noise machine and complementary ear plugs are not enough. The rooftop bar that closed early in evening was great.
4out of 5
by A verified traveller

Great in town location

Posted 05-Oct-2015
Pros: location
Cons: No AC so had to open window for air but lucky it wasn't a hot day.
Beautiful old hotel, in town with nice restaurant. We had second floor front windows overlooking street. A bit noisy at night as it was over the bar. Good place for breakfast.
4out of 5
by Richard from Scottsdale

Make sure you get the right room

Posted 27-Sep-2015 on Hotels
This is totaly depending on your room. The firt room was completely claustrfobic. Dark and hardly any window, View was a brick wall 3 feet from the window and no vew of the sky above. WE WALKED OUT. Then they gave us a room with a street view. We loved it, we loved the restaurant, the dining and the breakfast... and not at least the location