Ratings based on 21 Verified Reviews

4.2 out of 5
100% of guests recommend
4.5 Room cleanliness
4.7 Service & staff
4.2 Room comfort
4.3 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
5out of 5
for Everyone
by A verified traveller from Huddersfield

Lovely traditional pub with restaurant

Posted 19-Dec-2016
Pros: Traditional nature of the pub, the staff and the food.
We had a really lovely weekend at Blacksmiths Arms Inn. The staff are very friendly and willing to help. The food is great home cooking using good local produce. Delicious! Good location on the main road to Scarborough and Robin Hood's Bay.
5out of 5
for Couples
by A verified traveller

Blacksmiths Arm Welcome

Posted 20-Sep-2016
Pros: Everything
Cons: Absolutely nothing
Location: Location is great near to Scarborough and Whitby - well it is if you have a car Couple of pubs nearby and a delightful tearoom
Stayed here several times. The hotel is excellent, the staff are amazing, the food is so gorgeous - just too much of it ! The rooms (and we have several different ones) are warm, inviting and immaculate. All have TVs and tea making facilites with an ample choice of tea, coffee, hot chocolate, all are en-suite and the bathrooms are spotless along with a good supply of towels and comp toiletries. Plenty of car parking space The only downside to this place is time passes too quickly ! Great place to stay and i would happily recommend it.
4out of 5
by A verified traveller

This traveller left a rating score only Posted 13-Sep-2016 on Hotels
4out of 5
by A verified traveller


Posted 05-May-2016 on Hotels
Staff were very friendly and accommodating. Sadly the rooms were a little stuffy (no air con) and noisy - could hear when taps turned on elsewhere in the building.
5out of 5
by John from Cleethorpes

A place just for you.

Posted 24-Mar-2016 on Hotels
It was great to stay there, as I stayed there many years ago when the Farther of the present Landlord had it. They came from the same village in South Yorkshire were we are from. It's position for the Bus to Whitby & Scarborough is great no more than 5 yards to Whitby & 10 yards to Scarborough. Meals very good and well priced. Well keep beer especially the real ales. I would recommend this place to anyone. Don't tell to many people as it will be full & we want be able to get booked in. Like the quote form Arnold Schwarzenegger We will be back from Mr J.& V. Jones
4out of 5
by A verified traveller

Wedding at Raven Hall Hotel

Posted 12-Sep-2015 on Hotels
We booked the Blacksmiths Arms as we were unable to get a room at Raven Hall Hotel where we were going to a wedding. The room and bathroom were good sizes and suited what we needed. Plenty of choice for breakfast. Our only complaints would be that the shower wasn't very powerful and was a bit of a pain to get the right temperature and that someone (presumably from the hotel) walked in on us without knocking while we were finishing getting ready. Bed was very comfy. Toiletries had been left in the bathroom. Tea/coffee was available in the bedroom. Overall, a lovely stay!
4out of 5
by A verified traveller

Posted 31-Aug-2015 on Hotels
Very personalised service.,
5out of 5
by A verified traveller

Loved it!

Posted 25-Aug-2015 on Hotels
Lovely pub/hotel. Thoroughly enjoyed our stay - wished it could have been longer. Staff very friendly and helpful. Lovely walk to coast path within 20 minutes.
4out of 5
by David from North East

Cosy pub/hotel

Posted 08-May-2015 on Hotels
A very pleasant cosy pub/ hotel. Room was very comfortable. Great full English breakfast!
4out of 5
by ANDREW from Gomersal

Nice restaurant, good pub. Theakstons Best great!

Posted 10-Mar-2015 on Hotels
Nice restaurant. Good Pub. Theakstons a Best was best beer I've tasted for a long time. Food was lovely. People friendly. Great position for Coastal Path walks.