Ratings based on 706 Verified Reviews

They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.4 out of 5
93% of guests recommend
4.5 Room cleanliness
4.3 Service & staff
4.5 Room comfort
4.4 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
We double-checked.
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified travellerfrom Raleigh, NC

Keys Perfection

Posted 01-Mar-2015
Pros: Spectacular setting. Lush and tropical. Love it!
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Cheeca Lodge was much more than we expected. It's a completely self-contained resort and you don't really have to leave the property. It's all there. Gorgeous beach with meticulously groomed white sand, but not so much a swimming beach. Beautiful pier. I recommend you take advantage of one of the bikes included in your resort fee and ride around the very large and lush property.
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified travellerfrom aurora il

great place I really have no complaints

Posted 25-Feb-2015
Pros: pretty much everything
Cons: the weather was a bit chilly
Location: restaurants and shops nearby the traffic was a problem however probably the time of the year
clean,classy the adult pool and spa were enjoyable room was great balcony great with screened in so no bugs and separated from your neighbors
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified travellerfrom Brooklyn, NY

Posted 19-Feb-2015
Champagne at check-in. Free run of the resort. Courteous staff. Hidden jacuzzis. The entire stay was the highlight of my week in Florida. No need to explore elsewhere!
4 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified travellerfrom Texas

Very nice hotel

Posted 17-Feb-2015
I have stayed there multiple times during the past 4-5 years and just returned from a long weekend stay. The hotel facilities are very nice in a beautiful setting. The service personal is nice, but VERY unprofessionally trained restaurant staff. VERY slow service, VERY slow check out. Poorly trained chaotic staff, otherwise great.
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified traveller

Wonderful

Posted 16-Feb-2015
Wonderful stay...will go back. Pros, location, big room, great bathroom, great deck ...we had oceanfront, grounds for walks and biking. Cons...our fan did not work, and restaurant staff, some, were extremely slow. Other than that it was great!
4 out of 5
by A verified travellerfrom Amelia Island FL

Room Location

Posted 16-Feb-2015
Pros: eating facilities and wait staff; the view was wonderful and they had great facilities.
Cons: Friendly, get room reserved that shows when you reserve it and administrative staff that care more about their guest
Location: great location with restaurants near by and off property activities were plentiful
The room I reserved for over $1800 for 3 nights had an Atlantic view from the hotel. we were put out in a remote building that only looked over the little golf course and trees--no Ocean. The service was very good not much personality from some of the administrative staff but all pleasant. I would not recommend due mainly for the high cost where we had no view. Again I clicked on two queen beds with an Atlantic Ocean view over the Hotel Pier. I feel like they put us remote due to my booking through Expedia for the highest rate that I have "EVER" personally paid and I have been to many excellent places in the USA for less per day rate with much nicer rooms and administrative staff. When I checked out the lady did not ask about my stay. Butch Lambert
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified travellerfrom North Carolina

Beautiful tropical paradise

Posted 13-Feb-2015
Pros: Great room with great views
Cons: Maid service is slow..
Location: We rented a boat and went fishing. There is a putt putt course not too far away and alot of good restaurants
The drive to the Lodge takes you through a beautiful tropical paradise. Seriously, the landscaping is breathtaking. We had a suite and a screened in porch to enjoy the morning and evenings. The way the rooms are set up, you don't even realize you have neighbors because you don't see them when you are sitting on your porch with your tea or coffee. Very nice touch. There are alot of activities to do, snorkeling, fishing, kayaking and jet skiing, but it was a little too cool to partake when we were there in February. There are alot of nice restaurants nearby, fresh fish everywhere! We had a very relaxing time here, and were able to re-charge very nicely. The ONLY complaint would be that the maid service is very slow. We got our room cleaned around 4:00 every day. I would recommend this place anyway because it is just so very beautiful.
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Families
by A verified traveller

Beach hideaway

Posted 13-Feb-2015
Pros: Everything. The restaurants, the beach, the pools, the golf course and the staff
Location: The location is perfect there are tons of shopping and dinning opportunities within walking fistance
We loved Cheeca. The staff was great, very friendly. The beach was beautiful and very relaxing. The golf course is a great place to spend time with your kids. The pools are great and very well maintained. Cheeca's location is so private but you are right in the heart of Islamorada.
3 out of 5
by A verified travellerfrom pollack

nice facility. mediocre service, mediocre restaura

Posted 10-Feb-2015
Pros: good whirlpool.
Location: nice restaurants in the area.
needs more professional management, seemed like there was lots of staff just standing around.
4 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified travellerfrom NC

Unhappy at checkout

Posted 07-Feb-2015
Pros: We loved the beach, pools, and water sports. There were plenty of chairs.
Cons: Remove the foliage from blocking the view from the balcony. It makes the room feel too close.
Location: Plenty of fishing and sights to see.
The resort fee was brought to my attention at checkout, which made this good deal from Expedia not such a good deal. Though the food and drink at the restaurants was good, it was extremely expensive. The only comfortable seating in the room was on the bed. A chair for reading or TV watching would have been more comfortable.